Remedial Media Literacy

The Party Switch:
How the Parties Traded Places

“Republicans can’t be the racists, because we freed the slaves.” The history behind that line is real. What it leaves out is the next hundred years: how the two parties traded places on civil rights, when it happened, and why.

November 16, 2026 · Emily Adams · 51 Nodules · 77 Sources
Debunked“Republicans can’t be the racists, because we freed the slaves.”

Your Rebuttal, Ready to Paste

Yes, Republicans freed the slaves. Then, over the next century, the parties traded places. In 1964 the Civil Rights Act vote split by region, not party: most Northerners in both parties voted yes, and most Southerners in both parties voted no. The Democrats who fought for civil rights stayed Democrats. The voters who defended segregation moved, over a generation, to the Republicans. Sources: https://emilyadams.net/remedial-media-literacy/the-party-switch/

Download the Graphic
Rebuttal graphic: Yes, Republicans freed the slaves. Then, over the next century, the parties traded places. In 1964 the Civil Rights Act vote split by region, not party: most Northerners in both parties voted yes, and most Southerners in both parties voted no. The Democrats who fought for civil rights stayed Democrats. The voters who defended segregation moved, over a generation, to the Republicans.

Watch Concordia explain it in two parts, or read the full story below.

Part 1 The 1860s to 1936
Part 2 1948 to Today
How to Read This: every glowing word opens a branch. Branches hold more glowing words. Follow any trail as deep as it goes.

The Claim

It turns up under almost every argument about race and politics: “Well, they don’t tell you that the Republicans are the ones that freed the slaves, so we can’t be the racist ones.” The reasoning behind it goes like this: Democrats defended slavery and Jim Crow, so they must still be the racist party.

The history is real, and at a quick glance it sounds like it makes sense. What it skips is how the parties . Neither party kept the same voters for a century and a half. White Southern voters moved from the Democrats to the Republicans, and Black voters moved from the Republicans to the Democrats. Here is how, when, and why it happened.

Lincoln’s Republicans End Slavery

In the 1860s, Republicans ended slavery and made Black Americans citizens and voters, through : the 13th ended slavery, the 14th made citizenship and equal protection national guarantees, and the 15th barred any state from denying the vote on account of race.

Democrats, then the party of the white South, fought all of it. They used constitutional arguments, economic warnings, , restrictive state laws, and, in parts of the South, intimidation and violence.

What is revealing is how they framed it. They called federal protection of Black civil rights an attack on white Americans’ freedoms, on , and on constitutional government. In 1868 the Democratic ticket of Horatio Seymour and Francis Blair campaigned under a badge that said it plainly:

The Black Codes and the Klan

Right after the war, all-white Southern legislatures, led by former Confederates, passed to restrict freedom: required labor contracts, vagrancy laws that punished unemployment, and limits on Black Americans’ economic independence. Some let Black people who were arrested be . The effect was to preserve much of the plantation labor system without formally restoring slavery.

White supremacist groups, including the , attacked Black citizens and the white Republicans who supported them, to scare them out of politics. In 1874 the cartoonist drew a Klansman and a White League member shaking hands over a terrorized Black family, and titled it “Worse than slavery.”

Reconstruction, and How It Ended

From 1865 to 1877, Republicans in Washington worked to rebuild the South and protect the rights of the formerly enslaved, with federal troops when needed. This is called . For a few years it changed who held power: Southern states sent the to Washington, and every one of them was a Republican.

It came apart over a decade, not in a day. By 1877, Northern voters had grown tired of Reconstruction, the Supreme Court had narrowed the new amendments in the of 1873 and in 1876, and Democrats had retaken most Southern states. That year the new Republican president, , withdrew the federal troops that were propping up the last Reconstruction governments, in Louisiana and South Carolina.

Ninety Years of Jim Crow

Southern Democrats took back control and built : segregation, and laws designed to keep Black citizens from voting, such as . With Washington no longer enforcing the 14th and 15th Amendments in the South, Jim Crow lasted for nearly ninety years, until the civil rights laws of the 1960s.

For about sixty of those years, political loyalty rested mostly on what the two parties had done during the Civil War and Reconstruction. White Southerners voted Democratic, so reliably that the region was called the . Black Americans, where they could still vote, mostly in the North, .

The New Deal Changes the Math

The changed political priorities. Black Americans were especially vulnerable to unemployment, discrimination and poverty, but in most still stuck with the Republicans, out of loyalty to Lincoln and emancipation.

Democratic President took office in 1933 and introduced the , a series of federal programs to provide relief, create jobs, and reform the banks so the country could recover. Black families got an unequal, often share, and at first left out farm and household work, jobs many Black workers held. But it was real help, and allies like and pushed for more. Republicans offered little.

In , most Black voters chose the Democrat.

One Party, Both Sides

That left the Democratic Party holding both sides of the fight over civil rights: Black voters and Northern liberals on one side, and the segregationist white South on the other. Those two groups were never a match. Something had to give.

The Dixiecrat Walkout

In 1948, Democratic President pushed civil rights. When the party’s convention adopted a civil rights plank, Southern segregationists walked out and formed the , whose platform said:

But the Dixiecrats did not simply leave the Democrats and become Republicans. They ran as the “States’ Rights Democratic Party,” and in the they were the official Democratic ticket. Most of them came crawling back, then fought civil rights legislation from inside their own party, using , and the threat of them, against civil rights bills in 1957, 1960 and 1964, and resisted the growing influence of Northern Democrats who supported racial equality.

Meanwhile, Republicans were increasingly divided between their traditional civil rights supporters, such as and Senate leader , and a growing conservative movement that emphasized limited federal government and pushed “states’ rights.” Remember that phrase.

1964: The Vote by Party, and by Region

In 1964, Democrat signed the . Republicans in Congress than Democrats did. That number is real, and it is the one the comment section quotes.

Now sort the same vote . Most Northerners in both parties voted yes. Most Southerners in both parties voted no. The real dividing line was region. Southern lawmakers, elected by white voters while most Black Southerners were , defended segregation. Northern lawmakers in both parties backed civil rights. Democrats held most of the Southern seats, so most of the no votes were theirs, and that is why their party total was lower.

Thurmond, Goldwater and the Southern Strategy

That year, , the 1948 Dixiecrat candidate and by then a Democratic senator, switched to the Republicans. Their nominee for president, , had voted against the Civil Rights Act. He lost badly, but he , along with his home state of Arizona.

Republican strategists took note. From to , they courted white Southern voters with like “law and order,” “states’ rights,” “forced busing,” “soft on crime,” and more. One Republican strategist, , admitted it on tape in 1981: openly racist language had started to backfire and cost votes, so campaigns switched to abstract words that sent the same signal without saying it outright.

A Slow Switch

It happened slowly: first in , then for Congress, then in state capitols, as older voters gave way to their children and grandchildren. By , Republicans held most of the South’s seats in the U.S. House for the first time since Reconstruction.

Economists who went back to decades of survey data found that race drove it. in the American Economic Review found that the defection of white Southerners with conservative views on race explains the entire decline in white Southern Democratic identification from 1958 to 1980.

So Yes, Republicans Freed the Slaves

So yes, Republicans freed the slaves. But over the next century, the parties traded places. The Democrats who fought for civil rights stayed Democrats. The voters who defended segregation moved, over a generation, to the Republicans.

You may find some super interesting parallels between then and now. As always, please fact check me. You’ll be surprised what you find when you go looking. For the full story of how the coded language works, read .

The Trail Map

Every nodule in one place. Choose one and the page opens the trail that leads to it.

Sources

Every source cited in the branches. Quotations credited to a journalist or scholar are given as that writer reported them.

  1. Alexander Gardner, Abraham Lincoln, November 8, 1863 (Library of Congress)
  2. Biographical Directory of the U.S. Congress, “Thurmond, James Strom”
  3. C. Vann Woodward, “The Not-So-New Deal,” New York Review of Books, December 8, 1983 (review of Nancy Weiss, Farewell to the Party of Lincoln)
  4. Christian Science Monitor, November 18, 1994, on the South’s new House majority
  5. Civilian Conservation Corps, Richmond, Virginia, Co. 1372 and 1375, cabinet making class (FDR Library, National Archives, Identifier 197152)
  6. Congressional Research Service, African American Members of the United States Congress, RL30378
  7. Currier and Ives, The first colored senator and representatives, in the 41st and 42nd Congress of the United States, 1872 (Library of Congress)
  8. Democratic Party Platform of 1868 (The American Presidency Project)
  9. Democratic Party Platform of 1948 (The American Presidency Project)
  10. Edmonston Studio, Harry S. Truman, 1945 (Library of Congress)
  11. Eisenhower Presidential Library, “Civil Rights: The Little Rock School Integration Crisis”
  12. Elias Goldensky, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, 1933 (Library of Congress)
  13. Emily Adams, “The Code Word,” It Worked Last Time, Part 1
  14. Encyclopedia of Alabama, “Dixiecrats”
  15. Federal Judicial Center, U.S. v. Cruikshank (1876)
  16. Federal Judicial Center, “The Ku Klux Klan Trials, 1871 to 1872”
  17. Franklin D. Roosevelt Presidential Library, “Eleanor Roosevelt”
  18. Franklin D. Roosevelt Presidential Library, “Roosevelt and Race” (exhibit panel 5.3)
  19. Gordon Parks, Dr. Mary McLeod Bethune, Bethune-Cookman College, January 1943 (Library of Congress)
  20. Harry S. Truman, Special Message to the Congress on Civil Rights, February 2, 1948 (Truman Library)
  21. Ilyana Kuziemko and Ebonya Washington, “Why Did the Democrats Lose the South? Bringing New Data to an Old Debate,” American Economic Review 108, no. 10 (2018): 2830 to 2867
  22. John Vachon, Drinking fountain on the county courthouse lawn, Halifax, North Carolina, April 1938 (Library of Congress)
  23. Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies, research on the Black vote in the 1936 presidential election
  24. Larry DeWitt, “The Decision to Exclude Agricultural and Domestic Workers from the 1935 Social Security Act,” Social Security Bulletin 70, no. 4 (2010)
  25. Mathew Brady studio, Rutherford B. Hayes, between 1870 and 1880 (Library of Congress)
  26. Miller Center, University of Virginia, “Rutherford B. Hayes: Domestic Affairs”
  27. Mississippi Encyclopedia, “Dixiecrats”
  28. Nancy Bercaw, “Black Codes,” Mississippi Encyclopedia
  29. National Archives, 13th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution: Abolition of Slavery (1865)
  30. National Archives, 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution: Civil Rights (1868)
  31. National Archives, 15th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution: Voting Rights (1870)
  32. National Archives, 1944 Electoral College Results
  33. National Archives, 1948 Electoral College Results
  34. National Archives, 1964 Electoral College Results
  35. National Archives, 1968 Electoral College Results
  36. National Archives, 1976 Electoral College Results
  37. National Archives, 1980 Electoral College Results
  38. National Archives, 1988 Electoral College Results
  39. National Archives, Civil Rights Act (1964)
  40. National Archives, Executive Order 9981: Desegregation of the Armed Forces (1948)
  41. National Archives, Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)
  42. National Archives, Social Security Act (1935)
  43. National Archives, Voting Rights Act (1965)
  44. National Archives, “The Civil Rights Act of 1964: Senate Roll Call”
  45. National Constitution Center, Mississippi and South Carolina Black Codes (1865), text
  46. National Governors Association, “Gov. Orval Eugene Faubus”
  47. National Park Service, Home of Franklin D. Roosevelt, “Mary McLeod Bethune”
  48. National Park Service, “Mary McLeod Bethune: The Presidential Advisor”
  49. Oyez, The Slaughter-House Cases, 83 U.S. 36 (1873)
  50. Pew Research Center, “Behind Biden’s 2020 Victory,” June 30, 2021 (validated voters)
  51. Platform of the States Rights Democratic Party, 1948 (The American Presidency Project)
  52. Richard Nixon, Address Accepting the Presidential Nomination, Miami Beach, August 8, 1968 (The American Presidency Project)
  53. Rick Perlstein, “Exclusive: Lee Atwater’s Infamous 1981 Interview on the Southern Strategy,” The Nation, November 13, 2012
  54. Ronald Reagan Presidential Library, Lee Atwater Files, 1981 to 1982 (finding aid)
  55. The American Presidency Project, Election of 1948
  56. The American Presidency Project, Election of 1980
  57. Thomas Nast, “The Union as it was / The lost cause, worse than slavery,” Harper’s Weekly, October 24, 1874 (Library of Congress)
  58. U.S. Army, Operation Arkansas, the Little Rock Nine, 1957 (Wikimedia Commons)
  59. U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Political Participation (1968), pages 12 to 14
  60. U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Voting in Mississippi (1965)
  61. U.S. Department of Justice Voting Section table, “March 1965” (archived mirror; adapted from Grofman, Handley and Niemi, 1992)
  62. U.S. Senate, “About Filibusters and Cloture”
  63. U.S. Senate, “Civil Rights Filibuster Ended” (June 10, 1964)
  64. U.S. Senate, “Proponents Build a Strategy for Success” (Civil Rights Act of 1964)
  65. U.S. Senate, “The Enforcement Acts of 1870 and 1871”
  66. Unemployed men queued outside a depression soup kitchen opened in Chicago, February 1931 (National Archives, Identifier 541927)
  67. Voteview, House roll call 182, 88th Congress (July 2, 1964)
  68. Voteview, Senate roll call 409, 88th Congress (June 19, 1964)
  69. Wikimedia Commons, “Campaign badge, 1868” (reproduces the NYPL record)
  70. Wikipedia, “1866 Pennsylvania gubernatorial election” (Clymer the Democratic nominee; secondary source)
  71. Wikipedia, “1948 United States presidential election” (Truman not on the Alabama ballot; secondary source)
  72. Wikipedia, “Dixiecrat” (official Democratic ticket in four states; secondary source)
  73. Wikipedia, “Lee Atwater” (Lamis transcript, The Two-Party South, 1988 edition, p. 26; secondary source)
  74. Wikipedia, “States’ rights speech” (Reagan at the Neshoba County Fair, August 3, 1980; secondary source)
  75. “Our ticket, Our Motto: This is a White Man’s Country; Let White Men Rule,” Seymour and Blair campaign badge, 1868 (NYPL, Schomburg Center)
  76. “The Freedman’s Bureau!” Pennsylvania campaign broadside, 1866 (Library of Congress)
  77. “The Southern Shift,” Wilson Quarterly (archived copy), drawing on Earl Black, Journal of Politics, 1998

Concordia is the animated presenter of Remedial Media Literacy. The narration in both videos is Emily Adams’s script, checked line by line against the sources above. Photographs are public domain or carry no known restrictions; each credit is in its branch.

0 / 51 Explored Trail Map