Types of Government

Libertarianism:
The Smallest Possible State, from Minarchists to Anarcho-Capitalists

A philosophy that puts individual freedom first. The thinkers from Hayek to Nozick, the split between minimal-state and no-state libertarians, the left wing, and Argentina’s test under Milei.

November 21, 2026 · Emily Adams · 20 Nodules · 23 Sources
How to Read This: every glowing word opens a branch. Branches hold more glowing words. Follow any trail as deep as it goes.

What Libertarianism Is

A philosophy that treats individual freedom as the highest political value, and holds that the state should be as small as possible or, for some, absent. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy calls it a family of views. Libertarians take individual freedom as the paramount political value and see coercion as its antithesis. People can be forced to refrain from infringing the liberty of others, but “they cannot be coerced to serve the good of other members of society, nor even their own personal good.”

The label itself has a short history. Friedrich Hayek wrote in 1960 that in the United States, where it had become almost impossible to use “liberal” in its old sense, “libertarian” had been used instead, and he found it “singularly unattractive.” Murray Rothbard said libertarians had been “a polite word for left-wing anarchists” until his side captured the word ().

Within philosophical debates over justice, the Stanford Encyclopedia says, libertarian positions are most controversial on distributive justice: whether people may be taxed to fund others’ needs. Libertarians answer no, and they hold that rights of freedom of contract, exchange and occupation deserve the same seriousness as the right to choose one’s friends, clothes or religion.

Who Owns It: Private Property, Starting with Yourself

Libertarians typically endorse an economic order based on private property rights, freedom of contract and voluntary cooperation. The Stanford Encyclopedia says they usually regard the redistribution of wealth by democratic states as an unjustified use of coercion, as they do many forms of economic regulation.

The foundation is : individuals own themselves and may do what they choose so long as they do not violate the self-ownership of others. Robert Nozick, following Locke, argued that natural rights over one’s own person ground natural private property rights beyond the person. Not every libertarian agrees on land and natural resources: hold that unappropriated resources belong to everyone in some egalitarian way.

Who Rules: A Minimal State, or No State

Libertarians divide on whether any state is justified. libertarians accept a small state that protects rights and enforces contracts, and little else. Their argument is that any further involvement is off-limits in principle and likely to favor whoever is politically well-connected, so the minimal state is the only one that can structure a complex society in mutually beneficial ways.

Others say no state is justified. The right-libertarian version of the stateless theory is known as , and the left-libertarian version is left market anarchism. Libertarians also hold what the Stanford Encyclopedia calls the moral parity thesis: state actors have the same rights and duties as private citizens, so only a person’s consent can give anyone the right to do what would ordinarily violate rights. They therefore reject any fundamental distinction between public and private action, which separates them from republicans and neo-Kantians.

What Libertarians Believe

The core claim, as the Stanford Encyclopedia puts it for Rothbard’s school, is that the initiation of interpersonal force is unjust, combined with an understanding of property rights as essential to personal liberty. The economic argument comes from and : that dispersed knowledge cannot be gathered by a planner, and that prices created by market exchange carry it.

On human nature, libertarians do not need people to be good. They need people to be free to pursue different ends. Hayek wrote that liberalism is distinguished from both conservatism and socialism by the view that moral beliefs about conduct that does not interfere with others’ protected sphere “do not justify coercion.” The remedy for social problems is voluntary cooperation, not command.

What Libertarians Value

In rank order: liberty; private property and contract; voluntary association; and tolerance of different ways of life. Hayek held that neither moral nor religious ideals are proper objects of coercion, a view that separates libertarians from conservatives ().

The Stanford Encyclopedia notes the pattern: on social issues libertarianism tends to be left-wing, advocating freedom of association, cultural and religious expression and sexual liberation, and on foreign policy it opposes border restrictions and war (). What it will trade away is the redistribution and regulation that other camps treat as the point of government.

A Short History of Libertarianism

The Stanford Encyclopedia says libertarian theory inherits its political morality from the classical liberal tradition of Locke, Hume, Smith and Kant (), and a political sociology from the individualist anarchists Benjamin Tucker, Thomas Hodgskin and Lysander Spooner (). Mises’s 1920 essay started the calculation debate, and Hayek’s The Road to Serfdom appeared in 1944.

The movement took shape in the United States after the war. Rothbard became its major voice and co-founded the Cato Institute, the Center for Libertarian Studies and the Mises Institute (). Nozick’s Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) forced mainstream philosophy to pay attention (). Ayn Rand rejected the label in 1971 ().

The Branches of Libertarianism

The Stanford Encyclopedia distinguishes several lines. Left-libertarians say right-libertarianism is more comfortable with existing economic inequality. Left-libertarianism comes in two senses: one marries libertarian rights to a radical critique of class and the state, and the other differs on how much people can appropriate of unowned natural resources. Minarchism defends a minimal state. Anarcho-capitalism defends none.

Smaller currents include agorism, Samuel Konkin’s program of counter-economic activity outside the state, and crypto-anarchy, which Timothy May’s manifesto declared a specter haunting the modern world. Objectivism is a separate philosophy whose founder disowned libertarians. Left market anarchism is the left-libertarian stateless school.

Where It Has Been Tried

No country has been run on libertarian principles. The nearest case is Argentina under President Javier Milei, a libertarian in office since December 2023, whose government . The Libertarian Party has run candidates in the United States, with little success in the most recent presidential race.

Scholars also cite societies that lacked states. David Friedman argued medieval Iceland left law enforcement “entirely a private affair” for over three hundred years, and Peter Leeson found Somalis better off under anarchy than under government on nearly all of 18 indicators (). Argentina’s numbers are in .

The Case for It and the Case Against It

The Claim

“Libertarianism is a right-wing ideology.”

The Reply, Ready to Paste

The Stanford Encyclopedia calls that label “mistaken.” On social issues libertarians tend to be left-wing, and on foreign policy they oppose war and border restrictions. On economics, right-libertarians are comfortable with market inequality, while left-libertarians are not. The family covers both.

Defenders argue that freedom is the first value, that coercion for another’s good is paternalism, and that markets and voluntary cooperation outperform planning. They cite the knowledge problem and Argentina’s fall in inflation under Milei.

Critics make three arguments. G. A. Cohen argued that self-ownership, properly read, explains the unjustly exploitative nature of capitalism (). Noam Chomsky said in 1996 that anarcho-capitalism “would lead to forms of tyranny and oppression that have few counterparts in human history” (). And the Argentine record under Milei is mixed: inflation fell, but poverty rose again in 2026.

Both sides use Argentina. Supporters stress that austerity tamed inflation and that poverty remains below its early-2024 level. Critics stress that, as the AP reported, progress has lost momentum, unemployment is edging higher, and average salaries are below their level when Milei took office. The case rests on which year and which measure are chosen.

What Libertarianism Is Not

The Claim

“Ayn Rand founded libertarianism.”

The Reply, Ready to Paste

Rand wrote in The Objectivist in 1971: “I do not join or endorse any political group or movement,” and disapproved of what she called the “hippies of the right” who claimed to follow her while advocating anarchism. The Stanford Encyclopedia names Locke, Hume, Smith and Kant as the tradition’s roots and Rothbard as its major American voice.

It is not the same as anarchism, though the two overlap. Left anarchists regard anarcho-capitalism as a contradiction, and the Anarchist FAQ argues it is not anarchism at all. It is not conservatism: Hayek wrote that the conservative “does not object to coercion or arbitrary power so long as it is used for what he regards as the right purposes.”

It is not the same as liberalism, though the Stanford Encyclopedia places libertarians at one end of the classical liberal spectrum. And it is not Objectivism: Ayn Rand wrote in 1971 that she had “no connection with” the “hippies of the right.”

Libertarianism Today

The Libertarian Party’s 2024 showing was weak. Reason reported that Chase Oliver won about 30,000 votes in Florida, around 0.3 percent, trailing the Green Party’s Jill Stein, against more than 70,000 and 0.6 percent for Jo Jorgensen in 2020. It was the first presidential election since the Mises Caucus took over the party ().

The movement’s biggest test is abroad. In September 2026 Argentina reported that poverty had risen to 32.3 percent in the first half of the year, after falling to 28 percent in the second half of 2025, an eight-year low. Milei faces reelection a little over a year later, and his economy minister argues both poverty rates “remain sharply lower” than in early 2024.

The movement’s institutions remain. Rothbard co-founded the Cato Institute, the Center for Libertarian Studies and the Mises Institute, and they continue to publish libertarian work.

The Trail Map

Every nodule in one place. Choose one and the page opens the trail that leads to it.

Sources

Every source cited in the branches, in alphabetical order.

  1. AP via La Nacion, Argentina’s Poverty Rate Rises Above 30% Under President Milei (2026)
  2. Ayn Rand Lexicon, Libertarians
  3. Chomsky.info, Noam Chomsky Interview (1996)
  4. Chomsky.info, Notes on Anarchism (1970)
  5. David Friedman, Private Creation and Enforcement of Law: Iceland
  6. Encyclopaedia Britannica, F. A. Hayek (2026)
  7. Foundation for Economic Education, Hayek, Why I Am Not a Conservative (1960)
  8. Marxists Internet Archive, Kropotkin, Anarchism, Encyclopaedia Britannica (1910)
  9. Mises Institute, Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth (1920)
  10. Mises Institute, Rothbard, The Betrayal of the American Right
  11. Peter Leeson, Better Off Stateless: Somalia, Journal of Comparative Economics (2007)
  12. Reason, Libertarian Party Underperforms in Presidential Election (2024)
  13. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Anarchism (2025)
  14. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Friedrich Hayek (2024)
  15. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Liberalism (2025)
  16. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Libertarianism (2025)
  17. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Nozick’s Political Philosophy
  18. The Anarchist Library, An Anarchist FAQ
  19. The Anarchist Library, C4SS Market Anarchism FAQ
  20. The Anarchist Library, Konkin, New Libertarian Manifesto
  21. The Anarchist Library, Spooner, No Treason
  22. Timothy C. May, The Crypto Anarchist Manifesto
  23. UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Thingvellir

Image Credits

  1. John Locke, whose natural-rights argument libertarians inherit. John Greenhill. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  2. Ludwig von Mises, whose 1920 essay began the socialist calculation debate. Ludwig von Mises Institute. CC BY-SA 3.0. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  3. Friedrich Hayek at the London School of Economics, January 27, 1981. Flickr Commons. No restrictions. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  4. Ayn Rand, 1943. Photo portrait credited to "Talbot" (though not on original dust jacket). Published by the Bobbs-Merrill Company .. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  5. The Casa Rosada, seat of Argentina’s president, in Buenos Aires. Diego Delso. CC BY-SA 3.0. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
0 / 20 Explored Trail Map