Two Traditions, and the Buddha of History
Buddhism and Taoism often share a shelf labeled Eastern wisdom, but they start from different questions. Buddhism asks why life is so persistently unsatisfying and how that can end. Taoism asks how to live in step with the Tao, the Way that runs through all things. Both are philosophies with arguments and religions with temples, clergy, and rituals, and both carry a gap between what the tradition teaches and what a historian can prove. Buddhism is the larger and more countable of the two: about 324 million people in 2020, by the Pew Research Center’s estimate.
Tradition tells the story of Siddhartha Gautama, born into the ruling Shakya clan at Lumbini in what is now southern Nepal. Raised in luxury, he saw old age, sickness, and death, left his wife and young son, spent years in harsh self-denial, and then gave that up too. Seated under a tree at Bodh Gaya, he reached awakening, and he spent the rest of a long life teaching. The title Buddha means awakened one. When he lived is disputed: Western scholars long placed him around 560 to 480 BCE, many now put his death near 400 BCE, and the Theravada tradition dates him earlier still.
He wrote nothing. Monks memorized and chanted his talks for centuries, and the Pali Canon, the oldest complete collection that survives, may have been written down for the first time in Sri Lanka in the first century BCE. Scholars find later layers of language and doctrine inside it, so the careful phrase is that the early tradition remembers the Buddha saying something. The first hard evidence of Buddhism is carved in stone: the edicts of the emperor Ashoka, who ruled most of the Indian subcontinent in the third century BCE and marked the Buddha’s birthplace with a pillar.
The Diagnosis: Four Noble Truths and the Middle Way
The tradition says the Buddha’s first sermon, given to five former companions in a deer park near Varanasi, opened with a warning against two extremes: chasing sensual pleasure and punishing the body. Between them lay the Middle Way. He then set out the Four Noble Truths, often compared to a physician’s method. Life as usually lived is marked by dukkha, a word that covers pain, stress, and a background sense that nothing quite satisfies. Dukkha has a cause, craving. It can end. And there is a path that ends it.
That path is the Noble Eightfold Path: right view, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration. Teachers group the eight into ethics, meditation, and wisdom, and they are practiced together rather than in order. Underneath the path sits a short list of what goes wrong in a mind, often called the three poisons: greed, aversion, and delusion.
The early texts present the Buddha as a practical teacher who refused to be drawn into questions that did not help. When a monk demanded answers about whether the universe is eternal, the Buddha replied with the parable of the poisoned arrow. When he described his own teaching, he compared it to a raft: something to use for crossing, not to carry on your head once you reach the far shore.
Impermanence, No-Self, and Rebirth
Buddhist thought rests on three marks of existence. Everything conditioned is impermanent. Clinging to impermanent things is unsatisfactory. And nothing in a person, body, feelings, perceptions, mental formations, or consciousness, is a permanent self. The third mark, non-self, is the teaching that most sets Buddhism apart from the religions around it, and it is the one most often misread. It does not say that people do not exist. It says that what we call a person is a changing process with no fixed owner at the center.
The explanation of that process is dependent origination: things arise because conditions are present and cease when the conditions cease. The same chain explains suffering. Ignorance conditions habits of mind, which condition craving and clinging, which keep the cycle going. Break a link and the chain comes apart.
Classical Buddhism also teaches karma and rebirth: intentional actions shape future experience, in this life and in lives to come. That raises an obvious puzzle, rebirth with no self to be reborn, and Buddhist philosophers spent centuries on it. The goal of the whole path is nirvana, a word that literally means blowing out, as of a fire. What goes out is the fire of greed, aversion, and delusion.
Refuge, Precepts, and Meditation
A person becomes a Buddhist, in most traditions, by taking refuge in the Three Jewels: the Buddha, the Dharma (his teaching), and the Sangha (the community that practices it). Lay Buddhists then undertake the Five Precepts: to refrain from killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, and intoxicants. The precepts are framed as training rules a person takes on, not commandments from a god, and the early texts describe keeping them as a gift of safety to every being one might otherwise harm.
The emotional core of Buddhist ethics is a set of attitudes called the four immeasurables: loving-kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy in other people’s good fortune, and equanimity. They are meant to be cultivated deliberately, the way a musician practices scales, until they extend to everyone without limit.
Meditation is the best known Buddhist practice in the West and, historically, one practiced seriously by a minority, mostly monks and nuns. Classical teachers distinguish calm and insight: training the mind to settle and concentrate, and using that settled mind to see impermanence and non-self directly. The foundational text on mindfulness, the discourse on the four frames of reference, teaches attention to the body, feelings, mind, and mental qualities. For most Buddhists in Asia, everyday practice looks less like silent sitting and more like giving to monks, chanting, keeping precepts on holy days, and visiting temples.
Many Buddhisms
Buddhism spread south and east from India and took on the shape of each culture it entered. Today it has three broad families. Theravada, the doctrine of the elders, is strongest in Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia, and Laos and keeps the Pali Canon. Mahayana, the great vehicle, is strongest in China, Taiwan, Korea, Japan, and Vietnam. Its ideal is the bodhisattva, who vows to seek awakening for the sake of all beings, and its philosophy turns on emptiness, the teaching that nothing exists independently, given its sharpest form by Nagarjuna in the second or third century.
Inside Mahayana sit traditions that look very different from one another. Pure Land Buddhism, the most popular form in East Asia, centers on faith in Amitabha Buddha and chanting his name. Zen, called Chan in China, Seon in Korea, and Thien in Vietnam, prizes sitting meditation and direct insight over scholarship. Vajrayana, the diamond vehicle, adds tantric ritual, visualization, and a central role for the teacher, and is the form practiced in Tibet, Bhutan, and Mongolia.
Modern Buddhism is reshaping itself again. Women’s full ordination, which the early texts record and which later died out in Theravada countries, is being revived against official resistance. In the twentieth century the Vietnamese monk Thich Nhat Hanh coined the idea of engaged Buddhism, applying meditation to war, poverty, and injustice. And Buddhism reached Europe and America through translators, immigrants, and converts, where it often arrived as meditation without the monasteries, rituals, and rebirth that surround it in Asia.
The Old Master and His Book
Taoism traces itself to Laozi, whose name means Old Master. The standard story comes from the Han dynasty historian Sima Qian, writing around 100 BCE: Laozi lived at the Zhou court, Confucius consulted him, and when the dynasty declined he left for the west, where the keeper of a border pass asked him to write down his teaching before he went. The result was a book of about five thousand characters in two parts, the Tao Te Ching, the Classic of the Way and Its Power. Some modern scholars think there was never a historical Laozi, and most think the book grew over time rather than flowing from one pen.
Archaeology has narrowed the question. Two silk copies found in a tomb at Mawangdui, sealed in 168 BCE, showed that the text was nearly complete by the early Han dynasty. Bamboo slips from a tomb at Guodian, dated to around 300 BCE, hold about two thousand characters matching parts of the book, in different order and with some differences in wording. Many scholars now date the bulk of the text to the fourth century BCE.
Taoism’s second classic is the Zhuangzi, named for a philosopher of the late fourth century BCE. Where the Tao Te Ching is terse and often addressed to rulers, the Zhuangzi is funny, strange, and full of stories: a philosopher who dreams he is a butterfly, a cook whose knife never dulls, and an enormous tree that lives to a great age because its wood is useless.
The Way, Its Power, and Not Forcing
The Tao Te Ching opens by saying that the Tao that can be spoken of is not the constant Tao. The word means road or way, and in the book it names the source and pattern of everything, something that cannot be grasped by definition but can be followed. Its counterpart is de, usually translated virtue or power: the Way as it shows up in a particular thing or person.
Living by the Way means wu wei, usually translated non-action, which the text describes as doing nothing on purpose so that nothing is left undone. It does not mean laziness. It means acting the way water flows or a skilled craftsman works, without strain or self-assertion. Closely linked is ziran, naturalness, literally self so: things being what they are of themselves. The book’s image for a mind that has not been carved up by ambition and cleverness is the uncarved block.
Taoism shares with all classical Chinese thought the vocabulary of yin and yang, complementary forces such as dark and light that depend on each other, and qi, the vital energy that makes up and animates everything. The Tao Te Ching’s favorite image is water: soft, low, and yielding, and yet nothing wears away the hard and strong better. Its ethics come down to three treasures: in Legge’s translation, gentleness, economy, and refusing to put oneself ahead of others. And it has unusually pointed advice for rulers, captured in a line President Reagan quoted to Congress in 1988: govern a great nation as you would cook a small fish.
Taoism as a Living Religion
Western textbooks long split Taoism in two: a lofty philosophy of Laozi and Zhuangzi and a later popular religion of gods, priests, and magic. Scholars of Taoism now reject the split as too neat. The religion began, by its own account, in 142 CE, when the deified Laozi appeared to Zhang Daoling and founded the Way of the Celestial Masters, an organized church with priests, parishes, and scriptures. A second great order, the monastic Quanzhen school, arose in twelfth century north China. The two remain the main branches today, and their scriptures fill the Daozang, a Taoist canon printed in 1445.
Religious Taoism aims at long life, harmony with the cosmos, and, for its adepts, transcendence. Its methods include ritual, meditation, and inner alchemy, which reworks the old search for an elixir of immortality into a discipline of breath, energy, and visualization. The practices most Westerners meet, tai chi and qigong, descend from this tradition of cultivating the body, though most are now taught as secular exercise.
In China, Taoism never stood alone. For most of the last two thousand years it shared temples, festivals, and families with Confucianism and Buddhism, the Three Teachings, and ordinary people drew on all three without choosing one. When Buddhism arrived from India, translators borrowed Taoist vocabulary to explain it, and the Chinese school of meditation called Chan, the ancestor of Zen, came out of that meeting of the two traditions.
The Two Side by Side
Set next to each other, the two traditions answer different questions. Buddhism starts from a diagnosis, suffering and its cause, and offers a cure: a disciplined path that ends in release. Taoism starts from a picture of the world as a self-regulating whole and offers a way of fitting into it: less striving, less cleverness, more trust in what happens of itself. The Buddhist goal is to stop the cycle. The Taoist goal, especially in the religious tradition, is to live long and in tune with it.
They differ on the self. Buddhism says there is no permanent self to protect. Classical Taoism has a self but wants it simple, unforced, and unattached to status, a self that flows like water. Both distrust craving and ambition, and both arrive at similar advice for anger, attachment, and death: see the thing clearly, do not add a second wound to the first, and accept change. They differ on action. Buddhism asks for effort, right effort is part of the path, while Taoism praises not forcing. And they differ on setting. Buddhism built monasteries and a celibate order from the start; early Taoism pictured the sage in the mountains, and its monastic order came later, partly on the Buddhist model.
Both have something to say about rulers and power: Buddhism through the model of the righteous king, Taoism through its advice to govern as little as possible. And both have drawn comparisons to Greek and Roman philosophy, especially Stoicism, which also taught that much of human misery comes from judgments and desires a person can learn to change.
What the Research Says About Meditation
“Meditation is scientifically proven to cure anxiety and depression.”
The evidence is real but modest. A 2014 JAMA Internal Medicine review of 47 trials found mindfulness programs produced small to moderate improvements in anxiety, depression, and pain, and no evidence they beat other active treatments such as medication or exercise. A 2020 review found about 8 percent of participants reported a negative effect.
Meditation has become mainstream in the United States. Federal survey data show the share of American adults who meditated more than doubled from 7.5 percent in 2002 to 17.3 percent in 2022, making it more common than yoga. Most of it is mindfulness taught in a secular form, descended from programs such as Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction, which Jon Kabat-Zinn built at the University of Massachusetts.
The best known summary of the evidence is a 2014 meta-analysis in JAMA Internal Medicine by Madhav Goyal and colleagues at Johns Hopkins. It found moderate evidence that mindfulness programs modestly reduce anxiety, depression, and pain, low or no evidence for many other outcomes, and no evidence that meditation beat other active treatments such as drugs or exercise. In short, it helps some people somewhat, roughly as much as other good options.
Two critiques follow the boom. One, summed up in the word McMindfulness, argues that corporate mindfulness strips out Buddhist ethics and turns a path of liberation into a tool for making workers calmer about bad conditions. The other is clinical: a growing body of research on adverse effects finds that a minority of meditators report anxiety, depression, or disturbing experiences. Classical Buddhist texts never promised that meditation was relaxing. They treated it as powerful training that needed a teacher, an ethical foundation, and a community.
Quotes They Never Said
Both traditions are among the most misquoted on the internet. The single most famous Buddhist misquote comes from the Kalama Sutta, where the Buddha is made to say that you should believe nothing unless it agrees with your own reason and common sense. The real passage tells people not to rely on scripture, tradition, or a teacher’s authority, but it also warns against relying on logic, inference, and what seems likely, and it points instead to testing teachings by whether they lead to harm or to welfare when put into practice.
Many other sayings attributed to the Buddha appear nowhere in the canon. The real Dhammapada is blunter and stranger than the poster versions, and it is free to read. The same is true of Laozi. Lines such as watch your thoughts, they become words, or give a man a fish, are not in the Tao Te Ching at all, while some lines that sound too neat to be ancient, such as the journey of a thousand miles, are genuine.
When the Traditions Go Wrong
Buddhism’s reputation in the West as a religion of pure peace does not survive contact with history. The BBC’s guide to Buddhism and war lists Buddhist fighters in fourteenth century China and Japanese Zen masters who wrote in support of their country’s wars of aggression. In the twenty-first century the most serious case is Buddhist nationalism in Myanmar and Sri Lanka, where monks have led campaigns against Muslim minorities. In Myanmar that rhetoric preceded a 2017 military campaign that drove about 740,000 Rohingya into Bangladesh.
The second pattern is abuse by teachers. Tibetan Buddhism gives the guru extraordinary authority, and Western communities built around charismatic teachers have repeated the failures seen in other religions. An independent investigation found in 2018 that Sogyal Rinpoche, author of The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying, had subjected students to serious physical, sexual, and emotional abuse, and a 2019 investigation found it likely that the head of Shambhala International had committed sexual misconduct.
The traditions’ own texts condemn both. The first precept forbids killing, the simile of the saw forbids even inner hatred toward attackers, and the Tao Te Ching calls weapons instruments of evil omen. On teachers, the Kalama Sutta and other early texts tell students to judge a teacher by conduct over time, not by charisma or title, and the monastic code expels a monk for sexual intercourse. The traditions’ ethics of teachers read like a checklist of what went wrong.