The Two Books in Brief
A People’s History of the United States, first published in 1980, retells American history through the people who paid for it, and has sold millions of copies. Debunking Howard Zinn, published in 2019, follows it chapter by chapter and argues that it is not history at all but propaganda. This guide sets the two side by side: Zinn on the left, Grabar on the right, and under each pair a Check the Record box with what the evidence supports.
A note on sources. Zinn’s book was summarized from its chapters. Grabar’s book could not be read in full, so her side draws on its published excerpts and previews, passages posted by readers, her own interviews, and reviews; every branch names where its information comes from.
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
1980; revised through 2003; 25 chapters
Central ClaimAmerican history is a continuing conflict between a wealthy few and everyone else. Real gains in freedom came from pressure from below, and reforms were concessions sized to keep the system stable.
Zinn tells each period from the standpoint of those who lost by it, and says openly that no history is neutral. His method is history from below, written against the consensus history of the 1950s.
Point by Point
- Columbus and the conquest destroyed whole peoples, and calling it discovery is a choice to side with the conquerors.
- Racism was built in part to keep poor whites from allying with Black and Native people.
- Wars serve elites and turn domestic anger outward, including the ‘good war’ of 1941 to 1945.
- A comfortable middle group serves as a buffer and may one day side with those below it.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
2019; Regnery History; 9 chapters
Central ClaimZinn’s book is dishonest propaganda that misuses its sources, and its enormous influence has turned a generation of students against their country.
Grabar does not offer a rival narrative of American history. She audits Zinn’s: his sources, his omissions, his quotations and his politics. Her charge is that he would not survive the standards applied to other historians.
Point by Point
- Zinn’s famous opening on Columbus was taken from a popular book and misquotes Columbus’s log.
- He was a political activist first, with ties to the Communist Party documented in his FBI file.
- He makes his most contested claims as leading questions and leaves out evidence that cuts against him.
- His reach in classrooms is the reason the errors matter.
Check the Record
Both books are openly argumentative, and both are written by authors outside the academic mainstream of their subjects: Zinn a historian who rejected neutrality, Grabar a literary scholar writing about history. Mainstream historians have criticized Zinn’s book for decades, often from the left; Grabar’s book was praised mainly in conservative publications, including by several academic historians, and has drawn little scholarly criticism.
Questions
- What is each author trying to persuade the reader of, in one sentence each?
- Grabar writes a rebuttal, not a rival history. What can a rebuttal do that a narrative cannot, and what can it not do?
Method: History From Below vs. the Audit
Zinn: Chapter 1 and throughout · Grabar: Note and Introduction
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 1, ‘Columbus, the Indians, and Human Progress’
Central ClaimEvery history selects and emphasizes, so the honest historian states the point of view. Zinn chooses the view of the conquered and the poor.
Zinn writes that emphasis is itself a political choice, and that histories which mention atrocities and then move on to praise the conquerors, as he says Samuel Eliot Morison did, side with power without admitting it. He builds on other historians’ research and cites no footnotes.
Point by Point
- Openly partisan, by design.
- A synthesis of secondary works, with a bibliography.
- Asks of every policy who benefited and who paid.
- Treats reform as concession, not progress.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
A Note from the Author; Introduction, ‘Howard Zinn: Icon, Rock Star’
Central ClaimZinn’s stated point of view is a license to omit, splice and invent. Other historians were disgraced for less.
Grabar lists historians whose reputations suffered over fabrication or plagiarism and contrasts their treatment with Zinn’s continuing celebrity. She gathers earlier critics, among them Michael Kazin, Oscar Handlin and Sam Wineburg, to argue that the case against Zinn was made long ago but never reached classrooms.
Point by Point
- Zinn’s ellipses and omissions change what his sources say.
- He relies on a few secondary books, some of them popular rather than scholarly.
- Leading questions let him imply what he cannot show.
- His politics, not the evidence, decide what goes in.
Check the Record
Grabar’s method critique is not new, and much of it comes from historians on the left. Wineburg, a Stanford scholar of history education, documented Zinn’s reliance on secondary sources and his certainty where the record is disputed; Kazin called the book a fable of elites against the people. What Grabar adds is the scale of the charge, the biography, and the word fraud. See Zinn and Hans Koning.
Questions
- Is an openly partisan history more honest than one that claims neutrality, or simply easier to dismiss?
- Grabar cites critics from the left to make a case from the right. Does that strengthen or weaken her argument?
Columbus
Zinn: Chapter 1 · Grabar: Chapter One, ‘Columbus Bad, Indians Good’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 1
Central ClaimEuropean arrival in the Americas was a conquest driven by the search for gold and land, and it destroyed whole peoples. Telling it as heroic discovery is a choice to side with the conquerors.
Zinn opens with the Arawaks greeting Columbus with gifts, quotes the log on how easily they could be made servants, and follows the enslavement and collapse of Hispaniola’s population through the eyewitness account of Bartolome de las Casas.
Point by Point
- Columbus’s motive was gold, and his log shows he saw the islanders as labor from the first day.
- Las Casas, a Spanish priest who turned against the conquest, is the main witness.
- The population of Hispaniola was destroyed within a few generations by violence and forced labor.
- Treating this as the price of progress is a choice historians make.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter One
Central ClaimZinn’s opening was taken from Hans Koning’s popular book, and it distorts Columbus’s log so that Columbus looks like a greedy enslaver and the islanders uniformly gentle.
Grabar argues that Zinn’s ellipses hide the context of the ‘servants’ remark, that Columbus’s motives were largely religious, and that Zinn uses Las Casas selectively, skipping his reports of violence among Native peoples. She draws on other historians of the voyage.
Point by Point
- The quoted lines come from two different days, joined by Zinn’s ellipsis.
- Columbus ordered fair exchange and hoped to convert the islanders ‘by love.’
- Las Casas exaggerated, and Zinn goes beyond even Las Casas.
- Zinn’s account turned Columbus from discoverer into villain in American schools and civic life.
Check the Record
Both are partly right about the text. The log survives only in Las Casas’s abstract; Zinn’s quoted words are genuine, and he did splice lines from October 12 and 14 and drop a remark on conversion between them. The October 14 entry does contemplate conquest with fifty men, which critics of Grabar point out. On the catastrophe itself, historians agree the island’s population collapsed; they disagree about its size and the balance of disease and violence. The plagiarism charge is chiefly Grabar’s, though Zinn lists Koning as a source: see Zinn and Hans Koning.
Questions
- Read the October 12 and 14 entries yourself. Does the context Grabar restores change what the ‘servants’ remark means?
- Is relying heavily on a credited popular book the same as plagiarism? What would you need to see to decide?
- Why does it matter whether disease or violence caused most of the deaths on Hispaniola?
The Life of Zinn
Zinn: his memoir and the book’s closing chapters · Grabar: Chapter Two, ‘The Life of Zinn’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
You Can’t Be Neutral on a Moving Train (1994)
How Zinn Told ItZinn presents himself as a shipyard worker, war veteran and teacher whose experience of class, war and the civil rights movement made neutrality impossible.
In his memoir Zinn traces his politics to a working-class Brooklyn childhood, bombing missions as a bombardier in World War II, and his years at Spelman College and with SNCC, where he was dismissed in 1963 after supporting student protests.
Point by Point
- The bombing missions made him doubt the idea of a good war.
- The civil rights movement showed him that change comes from below.
- He taught at Boston University from 1964 to 1988 and opposed the Vietnam War.
- He denied being a member of the Communist Party.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter Two
Central ClaimZinn was a political activist first and a scholar second, with Communist Party ties in his past, who used his classrooms to recruit students into protest.
Grabar draws on his FBI file and papers and on his own writings, and recounts his years at Spelman and Boston University as a record of activism more than scholarship.
Point by Point
- Informants told the FBI he was a Party member from about 1949 to 1953; she calls him ‘very possibly’ a member.
- He kept ties to radical groups through the New Left era.
- His radicalism was a poor fit for Spelman, a Baptist women’s college, which dismissed him.
- At Boston University he clashed with the president, John Silber, over protests and grading.
Check the Record
The facts are documented; their meaning is argued. Zinn’s FBI file records informant reports of Party membership that he denied, and historians disagree about whether he joined. His dismissal from Spelman came without a stated reason after he backed student protests. A reviewer sympathetic to Grabar’s aims, Anna Abbott, judged parts of this chapter closer to a personal attack than a critique of ideas.
Questions
- Should an author’s politics or affiliations affect how we judge the history they wrote? When is biography relevant to argument?
- Grabar hedges in the book and speaks more firmly in interviews. Which should a reader hold her to?
Native Americans
Zinn: Chapters 1 and 7 · Grabar: Chapter Three, ‘Howard Zinn’s Usable Indian’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 1; Chapter 7, ‘As Long as Grass Grows or Water Runs’
Central ClaimNative societies were destroyed by conquest and dispossession, and their own values, such as shared land and the authority of women, show what was lost.
Zinn describes the Iroquois, with their common land and clan mothers, follows the Pequot War and the wars against the Powhatan, and later the Indian Removal Act and the Trail of Tears.
Point by Point
- English settlers made war on the Powhatan and the Pequot to take their land.
- The Iroquois held land in common and gave women real power.
- Removal in the 1830s was dispossession by fraud and force.
- Zinn concedes Native peoples were not completely peaceful, and gives that little weight.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter Three
Central ClaimZinn turns Native Americans into peaceful, egalitarian, proto-socialist innocents so that European settlement reads as the destruction of Eden.
Grabar argues that Zinn leans on Gary Nash’s survey while dropping Nash’s own cautions, and she sets evidence of intertribal war, captivity and torture against Zinn’s picture. She disputes his claim that Native women had higher status than English women.
Point by Point
- The Iroquois and the Pequot were themselves aggressive toward neighboring peoples.
- Zinn quotes Jesuit accounts of Native generosity and passes over their accounts of violence.
- Colonists are condemned even when resisting attack, as in King Philip’s War.
- Zinn’s picture of Native life serves a socialist argument about property.
Check the Record
The two books describe different things. Historians accept both that Native societies made war on one another, sometimes with great cruelty, and that English and American expansion dispossessed them through war, fraud and law, from the Pequot War to removal. The argument is over emphasis: Zinn foregrounds the dispossession, Grabar the violence that his account plays down. Neither fact cancels the other.
Questions
- Does evidence of war among Native peoples change the moral meaning of their dispossession? Why or why not?
- What is a ‘usable’ past, and is Grabar right that Zinn constructs one?
Slavery and Race
Zinn: Chapters 2, 3 and 9 · Grabar: Chapter Four, ‘America the Racist’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 2, ‘Drawing the Color Line’; Chapter 9, ‘Slavery Without Submission, Emancipation Without Freedom’
Central ClaimAmerican slavery and the racism that justified it were built by historical circumstances and law. They were not the result of a natural antipathy between races.
Zinn traces slavery from the Africans landed in Virginia in 1619 and the slave codes to Bacon’s Rebellion, and argues that emancipation came from enslaved people’s resistance and abolitionists’ pressure, with Lincoln acting when war required it.
Point by Point
- Racism was constructed by law, not natural.
- The color line was drawn to divide the poor.
- Emancipation was a war measure, and Reconstruction was abandoned in the deal of 1877.
- Enslaved people never accepted slavery; they resisted from Nat Turner to the Union army.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter Four
Central ClaimZinn treats slavery and racism as uniquely American and uses them against the country, while ignoring slavery’s worldwide history and America’s part in ending it.
Grabar argues that slavery was a world institution and that its abolition was a Western achievement, and she defends Lincoln’s antislavery record against Zinn’s account of political expediency.
Point by Point
- Zinn romanticizes African societies and passes over African and Muslim slave trading.
- A small share of the Atlantic trade came to the United States.
- Lincoln was elected on an antislavery platform and worked with Frederick Douglass.
- In her words, ‘Zinn will do anything to make America look bad.’
Check the Record
Both books use the same numbers to opposite ends. About 388,000 of the 10.7 million Africans who survived the crossing were landed in mainland North America, yet by the nineteenth century the United States held one of the largest enslaved populations in the Americas, because it grew by natural increase. Slavery’s worldwide history is not in dispute among historians; neither is the central place of slavery in American law and politics until the Civil War. Historians of emancipation credit both Lincoln’s policy and enslaved people’s flight to Union lines.
Questions
- Does slavery’s existence elsewhere change how Americans should judge American slavery? What would each author say?
- Who freed the slaves? Write Zinn’s answer and Grabar’s, then your own with evidence.
World War II
Zinn: Chapter 16, ‘A People’s War?’ · Grabar: Chapter Five, ‘Casting a Pall on the Finest Hour’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 16
Central ClaimWorld War II was fought against a real evil, but the United States did not fight it mainly for humanitarian reasons, and it emerged as an empire with a permanent war economy and a new enemy.
Zinn accepts that fascism had to be defeated and asks what the United States was fighting for. He notes that it acted only when attacked, kept its armed forces segregated, sent 110,000 Japanese Americans to camps, and did little to rescue Europe’s Jews. He condemns the fire-bombing of cities and the atomic bombs, which he argues were not needed to end the war. Afterward, the United States stands alone as a world power. It builds alliances and a permanent military economy against the Soviet Union, fights in Korea, and conducts loyalty investigations at home that destroy the Communist Party and frighten the wider left.
Point by Point
- The United States acted only when attacked and kept its armed forces segregated.
- Japanese Americans were sent to camps and the Supreme Court upheld it in Korematsu.
- The bombing of Dresden killed ‘more than 100,000,’ Zinn writes.
- The atomic bombs were not needed to end the war.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter Five
Central ClaimZinn recasts the good war as a contest between morally equivalent powers fought for profit, through leading questions and discredited figures.
Grabar argues that Zinn’s Dresden toll came from David Irving, later exposed as a Holocaust denier; that the Potsdam Declaration answers his claim that unconditional surrender blocked peace; and that the internment was reported at the time, not hidden.
Point by Point
- Zinn’s question about whether the war was fought against racism ignores what the Axis did.
- Japan rejected terms promising to withdraw once a peaceful government formed.
- Kamikaze attacks and civilian suicides showed Japan meant to fight on.
- Zinn is silent about Poland and plays down Japanese atrocities.
Check the Record
Here the evidence gives each side a point. On Dresden, Grabar, following Wineburg, is right: the toll was at most 25,000, and Zinn’s figure traces to Irving. On the incarceration, historians agree it was an injustice with no military necessity; whether the press hid it is a narrower question. On Hiroshima, Zinn takes one side of a live scholarly debate, and Grabar the other, while most recent scholarship sits between them.
Questions
- Zinn’s Dresden figure was wrong. Does one bad number discredit an argument, or only the claim it supports?
- Read the Potsdam Declaration. Does it support Zinn’s reading, Grabar’s, or neither?
- Can a war be just and still include acts that were wrong? How does each author handle that?
Communism and the Cold War
Zinn: Chapter 16 · Grabar: Chapter Six, ‘Writing the Red Menace Out of History’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 16, second half
Central ClaimAfter 1945 the United States built a permanent war economy and used anticommunism to justify intervention abroad and repression at home.
Zinn treats the Truman Doctrine as the start of an empire’s policy and McCarthyism as a bipartisan purge that began before McCarthy, and he stresses the weakness of the trial evidence against Julius and Ethel Rosenberg.
Point by Point
- Anticommunism at home was hysteria that destroyed the left.
- Loyalty programs began under Truman, a Democrat.
- The Soviet threat was exaggerated to justify military spending.
- Zinn mentions Soviet labor camps and the crushing of Hungary in 1956.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter Six
Central ClaimZinn writes Soviet espionage and communism’s crimes out of the story, so that American anticommunism looks baseless.
Grabar argues that Soviet espionage was real and extensive, citing the work on the Venona decrypts, and that the Rosenbergs were guilty. She faults Zinn for omitting communism’s toll and for portraying Soviet recovery favorably.
Point by Point
- Soviet sources reached the Treasury, intelligence, and the atomic program.
- Venona settled the Rosenberg case against Julius.
- The Soviet threat to Western Europe and Greece was real.
- Communist regimes killed on a vast scale.
Check the Record
The Venona decrypts, released in 1995, confirmed that Julius Rosenberg ran a Soviet spy network, and nearly all historians now accept it; Ethel’s role is still debated, and the chief witness against her contradicted himself. Zinn’s account predates Venona and was never revised. At the same time, the loyalty purges did reach many people who were not spies, which is the part of Zinn’s account historians still cite.
Questions
- Can both be true: that Soviet espionage was real, and that the anticommunist purge harmed innocent people?
- Zinn’s later editions did not account for Venona. How should a historian handle new evidence that cuts against an earlier argument?
Civil Rights
Zinn: Chapter 17, ‘Or Does It Explode?’ · Grabar: Chapter Seven, ‘Black Mascots for a Red Revolution’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 17
Central ClaimThe Black freedom movement erupted from long-stored anger and forced change through mass direct action. Federal civil rights laws were concessions that left poverty and the conditions of the Northern cities untouched.
Zinn follows the movement from Montgomery through the work of SNCC, with attention to local organizers over national leaders, and treats the civil rights laws as concessions that left poverty and the Northern cities untouched.
Point by Point
- The federal government was slow to protect activists.
- Malcolm X and the turn to Black Power expressed real anger.
- The FBI worked secretly to disrupt Black organizations through COINTELPRO.
- Langston Hughes’s question about a dream deferred frames the chapter.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter Seven
Central ClaimZinn used the Black freedom struggle as a vehicle for revolution, crediting Communists and militants while slighting the mainstream movement that won.
Grabar argues Zinn credits the wrong people: the Communist Party, whose handling of the Scottsboro case she says exploited the defendants, and the Black Panthers, over the NAACP and leaders like A. Philip Randolph.
Point by Point
- Polling showed most Black Americans rejected the Communist Party and favored the NAACP.
- Zinn played down the movement’s legal victories and its mainstream leaders.
- SNCC, which Zinn advised, turned to militancy and pushed the NAACP aside.
- Zinn praised King’s oratory but set it against the anger many Black Americans felt.
Check the Record
Zinn was a participant here, which gives his account both firsthand knowledge and a stake. Historians today credit both the movement’s pressure, which Zinn stresses, and federal action, from the courts to Johnson and Congress, which he plays down. The Communist Party’s role in the 1930s, including Scottsboro, is genuinely contested among historians. COINTELPRO’s campaign against Black organizations is documented by the Senate.
Questions
- Who deserves the most credit for the civil rights laws: organizers, national leaders, or lawmakers? How does each author answer?
- Is Grabar’s chapter title fair to Zinn? Is it fair to the activists it describes?
Vietnam
Zinn: Chapter 18, ‘The Impossible Victory: Vietnam’ · Grabar: Chapter Eight, ‘Ho, Ho, Ho Chi Minh!’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 18
Central ClaimThe most powerful nation in the world was defeated by a peasant revolution abroad and by the largest antiwar movement in its history at home.
Vietnam declares independence in 1945. The United States backs France’s effort to retake its colony, and after the French defeat in 1954 it supports an unpopular government in the South. In 1964 a disputed naval incident in the Gulf of Tonkin gives President Johnson authority to wage war. Half a million troops and unprecedented bombing fail to break the Vietnamese. At home, opposition grows from small protests to millions, including draft resisters, priests, and veterans, while discipline within the army itself breaks down. The Pentagon Papers reveal years of official deception. American troops leave in 1973, and Saigon falls in 1975.
Point by Point
- The United States backed France and then an unpopular government in the South after Dien Bien Phu.
- The Gulf of Tonkin Resolution rested on a disputed incident.
- My Lai showed what the war did to soldiers and civilians.
- The Pentagon Papers proved officials misled the public.
- Opposition at home, from students to veterans, helped end the war.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter Eight
Central ClaimZinn romanticizes Ho Chi Minh and the Viet Cong and is silent on what Communist victory brought.
Grabar argues Zinn’s account is one-sided: that Ho was a committed Communist, not a Jeffersonian, that Zinn quotes sources such as Douglas Pike selectively, and that he leaves out the land reform killings and the boat people.
Point by Point
- Ho’s declaration borrowed American words for a Communist state.
- North Vietnam’s land reform executed landlords in large numbers.
- Zinn quoted the Pentagon Papers selectively.
- The boat people and the refugee crisis are missing from his account.
Check the Record
Both men’s central facts hold. Ho Chi Minh was both a nationalist who quoted Jefferson and a lifelong Communist. What followed 1975, from re-education camps to the boat people to the Khmer Rouge, is well documented, and Zinn’s chapter ends before it. The land reform killings are real, though recent scholarship puts them in the thousands, below the older figures some critics cite. The government’s deception documented in the Pentagon Papers is also not in dispute.
Questions
- Should a history of the war include what happened after it ended? Where should a historian stop the story?
- Was Ho Chi Minh a nationalist or a Communist? Why does the answer matter to each author?
The Founders
Zinn: Chapters 4 and 5 · Grabar: Chapter Nine, ‘Howard Zinn, the Founders, and Us’
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Chapter 4, ‘Tyranny Is Tyranny’; Chapter 5, ‘A Kind of Revolution’
Central ClaimThe leaders of the Revolution redirected popular anger at local inequality toward Britain, creating a new nation that the same colonial elite could govern.
Zinn reads the Stamp Act riots, Common Sense and the Declaration as a colonial elite channeling popular anger against Britain, and the Constitution, after Shays’ Rebellion, as protection for property, drawing on Charles Beard and Federalist No. 10.
Point by Point
- The Declaration left out the enslaved, Native people, women and the poor.
- Poor men fought the war while the wealthy bought substitutes.
- The Constitution protected the property of its framers.
- Reform gave enough to the middle to secure its loyalty.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Chapter Nine
Central ClaimThe United States was founded to protect liberty, not elite wealth, and Zinn falsified that history.
Grabar argues Zinn misrepresents the Founders: that his thesis recycles Charles Beard’s discredited economic reading, that he ignores Founders who opposed slavery, and that he dismisses historians such as Gordon Wood who show the Revolution’s radicalism.
Point by Point
- About three quarters of colonists owned property.
- Loyalists, not Patriots, were more often the wealthy.
- Founders such as John Jay and Alexander Hamilton worked against slavery.
- Zinn contrasts the real Revolution with an imaginary egalitarian paradise.
Check the Record
The record supports both readings of the founding and slavery: the Northwest Ordinance and Northern abolition on one side, the three-fifths and fugitive clauses on the other. On Beard, Grabar is on firmer ground: later research found that the framers’ holdings did not line up with their votes as Beard claimed, though historians still study the founding’s economic interests. Both books end in a judgment about the present, which is where history most often turns into argument.
Questions
- Was the Constitution a document of liberty, of property, or both? Use one clause as evidence.
- Both authors end by talking about the present. What does each want the reader to do?
How Each Book Was Received
Howard Zinn, A People’s History
Reviews since 1980
Central ClaimPraised for giving voice to people left out of textbooks; criticized by historians across the spectrum for simplicity and certainty.
Eric Foner praised its energy and attention to the left-out and faulted its people for being only victims or rebels. Michael Kazin called it a fable of elites against the people. Sam Wineburg documented its handling of evidence. Its admirers, such as the Zinn Education Project, use it to teach the stories textbooks skip.
Point by Point
- Sales in the millions and wide classroom use.
- Critics on the left as well as the right.
- Never revised to reflect some later evidence.
- A political target, as in the Indiana emails.
Mary Grabar, Debunking Howard Zinn
Reviews since 2019
Central ClaimPraised in conservative publications as a thorough exposure; criticized as the work of a non-historian and, by a few reviewers, as partisan.
Favorable reviews came from Michael Burlingame, Wilfred McClay, Ronald Radosh and Robert Whaples, all writing in conservative or libertarian outlets. Mixed or critical responses came from a Portland State history chair, Anna Abbott and Paul Gottfried; David Detmer had answered her earlier writing.
Point by Point
- Several historians endorsed it, including scholars of communism.
- No full-length critical review by an academic historian was found.
- Even supporters called some chapter titles needlessly ideological.
- Radosh predicted its audience would be mostly readers who already agreed.
Check the Record
The two books have had very different receptions. Zinn’s has been reviewed, praised and criticized by leading historians for more than forty years. Grabar’s has been reviewed almost entirely within conservative publications, though by several historians, and rarely in history journals, so its specific charges have seldom been tested in public by scholars on the other side. That absence is not a verdict either way.
Questions
- Why might academic historians ignore a book like Grabar’s? Is silence a fair response?
- Whose praise or criticism of each book do you find most persuasive, and why?
Test Yourself
Answer aloud or on paper, then open each question to check.
What was Zinn’s method called, and what did it promise?
History from below: telling the past from the standpoint of ordinary and conquered people, with the author’s point of view stated openly.
What is Grabar’s academic training?
A doctorate in English from the University of Georgia. Her critics note she is not a historian by training.
Whose book does Grabar say Zinn’s Columbus opening came from?
Hans Koning’s Columbus: His Enterprise (1976). Zinn quotes and lists Koning; the plagiarism charge is Grabar’s own.
What did Zinn do with Columbus’s October 12 and 14 entries?
He joined lines from the two days with an ellipsis and omitted a remark about conversion between them. The words themselves are genuine.
Who preserved the surviving text of Columbus’s log?
Bartolome de las Casas, in an abstract partly paraphrased and partly quoted.
What does Zinn’s FBI file allege, and what did Zinn say?
Informants reported Communist Party membership from about 1949 to 1953. Zinn denied it, and historians disagree.
Whose survey of Native history does Grabar say Zinn relied on?
Gary Nash’s Red, White, and Black.
About how many enslaved Africans were landed directly in mainland North America?
About 388,000, of about 10.7 million who survived the crossing.
What Dresden death toll does Zinn give, and what did the Dresden historians’ commission find?
Zinn: more than 100,000. The commission, in 2010: at most 25,000.
Where did the inflated Dresden figures largely come from?
David Irving, later exposed as a Holocaust denier.
What does Grabar use to answer Zinn’s claim that unconditional surrender blocked peace with Japan?
The Potsdam Declaration of July 26, 1945, which Japan dismissed.
What did the Venona decrypts show about Julius Rosenberg?
That he ran a Soviet spy network. Ethel’s role is still debated.
What does Grabar’s civil rights chapter title argue?
That Zinn used the Black freedom struggle as a vehicle for revolution, crediting Communists and militants over the mainstream movement.
What does Grabar say is missing from Zinn’s Vietnam chapter?
The land reform killings in the North, and the boat people who fled after the Communist victory.
Which historian does Grabar say Zinn recycles on the Constitution?
Charles Beard and his 1913 economic interpretation.
Where did most favorable reviews of Grabar’s book appear?
In conservative or libertarian publications.
Essay and Discussion Prompts
Use both books and at least one Check the Record source in every answer.
Prompts
- Pick the one topic where you think Grabar lands her strongest blow, and the one where Zinn holds his ground best. Defend both choices with evidence.
- Both authors accuse the other side of using history for politics. Is it possible to write American history without a political point of view?
- Compare how each author uses quotation. Find one example of a quotation used fairly and one used unfairly, from either book.
- Grabar’s critics note she is not a historian; Zinn’s critics note his reliance on secondary sources. Which objection matters more, and why?
- Write the Columbus section of a textbook for ninth graders that would satisfy a fair reader of both books.
- On World War II, the evidence favors Grabar on one point, neither side on another, and stays open on a third. Explain all three.
- Should schools assign Zinn, Grabar, both, or neither? Make the case for one answer.
Read Alongside
To check both authors, start with the primary sources linked in each Check the Record box, and with Voices of a People’s History, Zinn’s own collection of documents. For criticism of Zinn from the left, read Michael Kazin and Sam Wineburg; for a defense of Zinn against his critics, David Detmer’s Zinnophobia. For surveys that cover the same ground, read Eric Foner’s Give Me Liberty! and Wilfred McClay’s Land of Hope, which come at the story from opposite directions, and James Loewen’s Lies My Teacher Told Me on how textbooks are made. For the companion to this page, see the study guide to Zinn’s book alone at emilyadams.net/a-peoples-history.