Types of Government

Socialism:
The Umbrella Idea, the Early Socialists, and the Family Tree

A family of ideas for putting the main economic resources under social control. The word, the early thinkers, the branches from utopians to African socialism, where it was tried, and the argument over what counts.

November 21, 2026 · Emily Adams · 26 Nodules · 68 Sources
How to Read This: every glowing word opens a branch. Branches hold more glowing words. Follow any trail as deep as it goes.

What Socialism Is

A family of ideas that put the main economic resources under public, social or collective control instead of private ownership. Britannica defines it as a doctrine calling for public rather than private ownership or control of property and natural resources. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy sets the minimum condition: the bulk of the means of production under social, democratic control.

Democratic socialism, communism and anarchism are the best-known branches of the idea. Around them sit older and stranger relatives, from utopian colonies to African and Melanesian socialisms. The dates to the 1820s and 1830s, and it has never had one meaning: the Stanford Encyclopedia notes a 1924 count of forty definitions.

Who Owns It: The Main Means of Production Under Social Control

Britannica says socialists have always disputed two things: how much property should be socialized, and whether control should be central or decentralized. Saint-Simon’s early version put the economy under central planning by scientists, industrialists and engineers. Owen turned to trade unions and cooperatives. Later models include market socialism, participatory planning and worker cooperatives such as Mondragon in Spain, which the Stanford Encyclopedia says had over 70,000 worker-owners by 2015. The are the heart of the argument.

What does not count is the welfare state. Britannica says tax-funded benefits and safety nets “don’t make an economy socialist.” Ownership and control of the means of production is the test, not how much government spends.

Even the early designs differed on private property. Fourier’s phalanx, a community of about 1,600 people, left room for private investment, while Saint-Simon’s followers advocated common ownership and the abolition of inheritance. The utopian socialists set the range of options the later branches argued over.

Who Rules: Anyone from Voters to a Vanguard

Socialism has no single political form. The Fabians sought a democratic socialist state by evolution rather than revolution. Germany’s Erfurt Program of 1891 demanded universal, equal, direct suffrage and a secret ballot for everyone over 20 “without distinction of sex.” , who founded a German workers’ association in 1863, dealt with Bismarck and imagined a monarchical welfare state with universal suffrage.

After 1917 another model arrived. Lenin’s 1920 Terms of Admission required parties joining the Communist International to call themselves Communist. Later, copied the Leninist vanguard model, and Egypt’s Arab Socialist Union was the sole legal party. Whether a regime is socialist and whether it is democratic are separate questions.

Some branches put rule in workers’ own bodies rather than the state. Guild socialists wanted workers’ control through national guilds, and syndicalists in France from 1900 to 1914 organized through the bourse du travail and aimed to end the state by direct action.

What Socialists Believe

The Stanford Encyclopedia lists the charges socialists bring against capitalism: exploitation, domination, alienation and inefficiency. Their remedy is to move the main means of production under social control. Many early socialists held that people are made by their circumstances. ran the New Lanark mills profitably without employing children under ten, and argued that human character is formed, not fixed.

The movement also holds that change must come from workers themselves. The rules of the in 1864 said “the emancipation of the working classes must be conquered by the working classes themselves.” Saint-Simon held that history moves in stages.

The branches disagree on method. Fabians favored evolution, Lassalle a legal route, Louis Blanc state-financed workshops, Owen cooperatives and unions, and syndicalists the general strike. They share the diagnosis and divide over how to act on it.

What Socialists Value

In rank order: equality first, then cooperation over competition, democratic control of economic life, and the freedom of people from drudgery and want. Oscar Wilde argued in 1891 that socialism would relieve people from “that sordid necessity of living for others.” Socialist feminists and the Black feminist Combahee River Collective later made the same value, work organized for those who do it, a basis for their own politics ().

What it will trade away is the market’s verdict on who gets what and the property rights of large owners. Americans surveyed by Gallup in 2018 said socialism means equality (23 percent, up from 12 percent in 1949) or government ownership or control (17 percent, down from 34 percent), according to .

A Short History of Socialism

The ancestors are old. Britannica names Plato’s Republic, the early Christian communities, More’s Utopia (1516), Anabaptist Muenster and the English Diggers. The word “socialist” came into use about 1830. The first great thinkers, the Saint-Simon, Fourier and Owen, wrote in the early 1800s, and proposed state-financed workshops in 1839.

Organization followed. A first international body met in London in 1864. Lassalle’s followers and the party of Bebel and Liebknecht united at Gotha in 1875. The Fabian Society formed in 1884, and the in Paris in 1889. In 1914 many parties backed their governments’ war efforts, and the Communist International of 1919 demanded a clean break. The movement split into communists, social democrats and others. Germany’s Social Democrats formally abandoned socialist ownership at Bad Godesberg in 1959.

The Branches of Socialism

The tree has many limbs. grew from British clergy after 1848. mixed state ownership with workers’ control. sought to abolish capitalism and the state by direct action, especially the general strike. turned a novel into a movement in the United States.

Outside Europe, socialism took local forms. African leaders in the 1950s and 1960s, Britannica says, built doctrines on communal precolonial life. appeared in Pakistan and Burma. In Vanuatu, . Democratic socialism, communism and anarchism, the better-known branches, are covered on their own pages.

Where It Has Been Tried

Small experiments came first. each lasted a few years. The of Israel, founded from 1909, are the longest-running experiment in common ownership. Tanzania’s began as a voluntary movement in 1967 and became almost compulsory by 1977.

National attempts varied. Nasser’s Egypt and Nehru’s India are covered in . In North America, won votes and governed. The larger national cases belong to the pages of democratic socialism (Britain, Sweden, Chile) and communism (the Soviet Union, China).

Voluntary membership separates the long-lived cases from the others. The kibbutzim and Mondragon, voluntary and small, have lasted decades. Ujamaa, which Britannica says became almost mandatory by 1977, is the contrast, and the utopian colonies of the 1800s ended quickly: New Harmony within a few years and Brook Farm after six.

The Case for It and the Case Against It

The Claim

“Socialism has failed everywhere it has been tried.”

The Reply, Ready to Paste

Which cases count is the dispute. The Institute of Economic Affairs lists over two dozen failures and says socialists call them not “really” socialist. The Stanford Encyclopedia notes a 1924 count found forty definitions, and regimes calling themselves socialist have ranged from Sweden to the Soviet Union.

Its defenders point to the charges against capitalism the Stanford Encyclopedia lists and to cooperative and public models that worked, from New Lanark to Mondragon. They argue that failures belong to particular regimes, not the idea. They answer the planning objection with market socialism, which keeps prices but makes firms social property, and with worker cooperatives. The Stanford Encyclopedia covers both sides of that exchange.

Critics make three arguments. Friedrich Hayek, a critic of what Britannica calls totalitarian socialism, said planning is a road to serfdom, and the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy lists the information, calculation and incentive problems of central planning (). The Institute of Economic Affairs counts over two dozen failed attempts. Catholic teaching under Leo XIII and Pius XI rejected it on religious grounds ().

What Socialism Is Not

The Claim

“Socialism means free stuff from the government.”

The Reply, Ready to Paste

Britannica says tax-funded benefits and safety nets “don’t make an economy socialist.” Socialism concerns who owns and controls the main means of production. Countries with large welfare programs, such as Denmark, call themselves market economies: Denmark’s prime minister said so at Harvard in 2015.

It is not the same as communism, though Marx used the words interchangeably. Engels wrote in 1888 that in 1847 socialism was a middle-class movement and communism a working-class one, and Lenin later reserved “socialism” for the first phase of communism. It is not social democracy, which regulates capitalism rather than replacing it, and it is not simply a big welfare state.

Engels also separated it from the older “utopian” schemes. His 1880 pamphlet Socialism: Utopian and Scientific contrasted Saint-Simon, Fourier and Owen with what he called scientific socialism.

It is also not one party’s property. India’s and Sri Lanka’s constitutions name socialism in their opening lines, and Portugal’s preamble opens a path toward it.

Socialism Today

The label is common and contested. The Socialist International counts 132 member parties, and the Party of European Socialists is an umbrella for socialist and social democratic parties. still carry the word. In the United States, on socialism, the first reading above 39 percent since 2010.

Young adults rate it higher than older ones, and Republicans and Democrats are far apart. Pew found in 2022 that 62 percent of Republicans and 19 percent of Democrats said socialism restricts freedoms.

The older institutions persist. The Fabian Society, founded in 1884, calls itself Britain’s oldest political think tank. Mondragon, begun in 1956, still lists 81 self-governing cooperatives. The kibbutzim, the Socialist International, and Tanzania’s constitution all keep the old vocabulary in use, whatever the practice behind it.

The Trail Map

Every nodule in one place. Choose one and the page opens the trail that leads to it.

Sources

Every source cited in the branches, in alphabetical order.

  1. Australian National University Press, Vanuatu, Chapter 14
  2. Australian National University, Buddhist Socialism and National Identity in Colonial and Postwar Burma
  3. BlackPast, The Combahee River Collective Statement (1977)
  4. Constitute Project, Bangladesh Constitution (2014)
  5. Constitute Project, Guyana Constitution (2016)
  6. Constitute Project, India Constitution (2016)
  7. Constitute Project, Portugal Constitution (2005)
  8. Constitute Project, Sri Lanka Constitution (2015)
  9. Constitute Project, Tanzania Constitution (2005)
  10. Dictionary of Welsh Biography, Owen, Robert (1771 to 1858)
  11. Encyclopaedia Britannica, African Socialism (2026)
  12. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Baath Party (2026)
  13. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Brook Farm (2026)
  14. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Charles Fourier (2026)
  15. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Christian Socialism (2026)
  16. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Edward Bellamy (2026)
  17. Encyclopaedia Britannica, F. A. Hayek (2026)
  18. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Fabian Society (2026)
  19. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Ferdinand Lassalle (2026)
  20. Encyclopaedia Britannica, First International (2026)
  21. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Gamal Abdel Nasser (2026)
  22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Guild Socialism (2026)
  23. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Henri de Saint-Simon (2026)
  24. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Histadrut (2026)
  25. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Icarian (2026)
  26. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Kibbutz (2026)
  27. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Louis Blanc (2026)
  28. Encyclopaedia Britannica, New Harmony (2026)
  29. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Second International (2026)
  30. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Socialism (2026)
  31. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Syndicalism (2026)
  32. Encyclopaedia Britannica, U Nu (2026)
  33. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Ujamaa (2026)
  34. Encyclopedia.com, Socialism
  35. Fabian Society, Our History (2026)
  36. Gallup, Image of Capitalism Slips (2025)
  37. Gallup, Socialism as Popular as Capitalism Among Young Adults (2019)
  38. Gallup, Socialism Positive Rating Tops 40% for First Time (2026)
  39. Gallup, The Meaning of Socialism to Americans Today (2018)
  40. Institute of Economic Affairs, Socialism: The Failed Idea That Never Dies
  41. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Socialism
  42. Jewish Virtual Library, History and Overview of the Kibbutz Movement
  43. Library of Congress, Egypt: A Country Study (1990)
  44. Library of Congress, India: A Country Study
  45. Library of Congress, Pakistan: A Country Study
  46. Library of Congress, Syria: A Country Study
  47. Marxists Internet Archive, Ehrenreich, What Is Socialist Feminism? (1976)
  48. Marxists Internet Archive, Engels, Preface to the Communist Manifesto (1888)
  49. Marxists Internet Archive, Engels, Socialism: Utopian and Scientific, Chapter 1 (1880)
  50. Marxists Internet Archive, Engels, Socialism: Utopian and Scientific, Chapter 3 (1880)
  51. Marxists Internet Archive, Erfurt Program (1891)
  52. Marxists Internet Archive, IWMA General Rules (1864)
  53. Marxists Internet Archive, Lenin, Terms of Admission into the Communist International (1920)
  54. Marxists Internet Archive, Nyerere, The Arusha Declaration (1967)
  55. Marxists Internet Archive, Wilde, The Soul of Man Under Socialism (1891)
  56. Mondragon Corporation, About Us (2026)
  57. Oklahoma Historical Society, Green Corn Rebellion
  58. Oklahoma Historical Society, Socialist Party of Oklahoma
  59. Pew Research Center, Modest Declines in Positive Views of Socialism and Capitalism (2022)
  60. Socialist International, About Us (2026)
  61. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Socialism (2024)
  62. The Canadian Encyclopedia, Co-operative Commonwealth Federation
  63. UNESCO World Heritage Centre, New Lanark
  64. University of Washington, Socialist Party of America
  65. Vatican, Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum (1891)
  66. Vatican, Pius XI, Quadragesimo Anno (1931)
  67. Victorian Web, Christian Socialism
  68. Vox, Denmark’s Prime Minister on Bernie Sanders (2015)

Image Credits

  1. Ferdinand Lassalle (1825 to 1864), founder of the first German workers’ party. Philipp Graff. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  2. Robert Owen (1771 to 1858), mill owner and early socialist. Percy Benzie Abery. CC0. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  3. Charles Fourier (1772 to 1837), painted by Jean Gigoux in 1835. Jean Gigoux. CC BY-SA 4.0. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  4. Louis Blanc (1811 to 1882), photographed by Carjat in 1848. Étienne Carjat. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  5. Edward Bellamy, author of Looking Backward (1888). Philpott. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  6. New Lanark, the Scottish mill community Owen ran from 1800 to 1829. Phil Barker. CC BY-SA 4.0. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  7. Degania, the first kibbutz, founded in 1909. Ben Herzberg. CC BY-SA 3.0. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  8. Gamal Abdel Nasser, president of Egypt from 1956 to 1970. Un credited. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
0 / 26 Explored Trail Map