Types of Government

MAGA, Measured

One question at a time, where does the Republican Party sit among every party that political scientists have scored? The answers come from a panel survey, not from opinion.

How to read the strips. Each strip is one question asked of political scientists. The first nine come from a late-2019 survey in which 50 experts rated the Republican Party; every grey dot is one party (847 parties in 127 countries, each rated by at least five experts). Eight more come from V-Dem V-Party, and a trait grid for whole regimes follows. The larger dots are named parties. The Republican Party is the orange dot. Scores run from 0 to 10.
Republican PartyMainstream partiesRight partiesFar-right partiesAll other parties

The short version

8.2Economics: 94th percentile of 809 parties
8.9Immigration: 89th percentile of 755 parties
8.2Ethnic minority rights: 89th percentile of 767 parties
8.3Respect for liberal democracy: 91st percentile of 803 parties
8.5Checks on the executive: 92nd percentile of 796 parties

The Republican Party ranks between the 87th and 94th percentile on seven of the nine questions and at the 78th and 79th on social values and populist rhetoric. Its highest rank is on economics (94th percentile, 8.2 against a median of 4.5), where the closest named parties are Likud (Israel) and UK Conservatives. On respect for liberal democracy it scores 8.3, the 91st percentile; the named parties nearest that score are Vox (Spain) (8.3), BJP (India) (8.3), FPO (Austria) (7.8).

Source one: the Global Party Survey, late 2019

Economic position

Economic left-right: from state intervention in the economy to free markets. File variable V4_Scale.
0246810Republican Party (US): 8.2Democratic Party (US): 3.7UK Conservatives: 7.9CDU (Germany): 6.9Conservative Party (Canada): 7.1UK Labour: 2.1Likud (Israel): 8.2BJP (India): 7.7Fidesz (Hungary): 2.7Law and Justice (Poland): 2.9AKP (Turkey): 7.3AfD (Germany): 6.9National Rally (France): 5.5Vox (Spain): 9.0Sweden Democrats: 7.3FPO (Austria): 7.2PVV (Netherlands): 4.1Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 8.9Golden Dawn (Greece): 6.3United Russia: 4.5Extreme leftExtreme right

Republican Party: 8.2, 94th percentile of 809 parties. The median party scores 4.5. Closest named parties: Likud (Israel) (8.2), UK Conservatives (7.9), BJP (India) (7.7).

9.0 Vox (Spain)8.9 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)8.2 Republican Party (US)8.2 Likud (Israel)7.9 UK Conservatives7.7 BJP (India)7.3 Sweden Democrats7.3 AKP (Turkey)7.2 FPO (Austria)7.1 Conservative Party (Canada)6.9 CDU (Germany)6.9 AfD (Germany)6.3 Golden Dawn (Greece)5.5 National Rally (France)4.5 United Russia4.1 PVV (Netherlands)3.7 Democratic Party (US)2.9 Law and Justice (Poland)2.7 Fidesz (Hungary)2.1 UK Labour

Social values

Social liberal to conservative values. File variable V6_Scale.
0246810Republican Party (US): 8.3Democratic Party (US): 2.4UK Conservatives: 7.1CDU (Germany): 7.5Conservative Party (Canada): 7.5UK Labour: 2.5Likud (Israel): 7.7BJP (India): 8.9Fidesz (Hungary): 9.2Law and Justice (Poland): 9.3AKP (Turkey): 9.3AfD (Germany): 8.8National Rally (France): 8.8Vox (Spain): 9.6Sweden Democrats: 8.7FPO (Austria): 8.1PVV (Netherlands): 4.9Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 9.7Golden Dawn (Greece): 9.9United Russia: 7.9Very liberalVery conservative

Republican Party: 8.3, 79th percentile of 822 parties. The median party scores 6.2. Closest named parties: FPO (Austria) (8.1), Sweden Democrats (8.7), United Russia (7.9).

9.9 Golden Dawn (Greece)9.7 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)9.6 Vox (Spain)9.3 AKP (Turkey)9.3 Law and Justice (Poland)9.2 Fidesz (Hungary)8.9 BJP (India)8.8 National Rally (France)8.8 AfD (Germany)8.7 Sweden Democrats8.3 Republican Party (US)8.1 FPO (Austria)7.9 United Russia7.7 Likud (Israel)7.5 CDU (Germany)7.5 Conservative Party (Canada)7.1 UK Conservatives4.9 PVV (Netherlands)2.5 UK Labour2.4 Democratic Party (US)

Populist rhetoric

Populist versus pluralist rhetoric. File variable V8_Scale.
0246810Republican Party (US): 7.8Democratic Party (US): 3.7UK Conservatives: 7.4CDU (Germany): 2.6Conservative Party (Canada): 5.1UK Labour: 5.1Likud (Israel): 9.1BJP (India): 8.6Fidesz (Hungary): 9.5Law and Justice (Poland): 9.5AKP (Turkey): 9.7AfD (Germany): 9.5National Rally (France): 9.2Vox (Spain): 9.2Sweden Democrats: 8.7FPO (Austria): 9.0PVV (Netherlands): 9.5Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 8.8Golden Dawn (Greece): 8.9United Russia: 7.2Strongly pluralistStrongly populist

Republican Party: 7.8, 78th percentile of 809 parties. The median party scores 5.7. Closest named parties: UK Conservatives (7.4), United Russia (7.2), BJP (India) (8.6).

9.7 AKP (Turkey)9.5 Law and Justice (Poland)9.5 PVV (Netherlands)9.5 Fidesz (Hungary)9.5 AfD (Germany)9.2 National Rally (France)9.2 Vox (Spain)9.1 Likud (Israel)9.0 FPO (Austria)8.9 Golden Dawn (Greece)8.8 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)8.7 Sweden Democrats8.6 BJP (India)7.8 Republican Party (US)7.4 UK Conservatives7.2 United Russia5.1 Conservative Party (Canada)5.1 UK Labour3.7 Democratic Party (US)2.6 CDU (Germany)

Immigration

Position on immigration. File variable V10.
0246810Republican Party (US): 8.9Democratic Party (US): 2.7UK Conservatives: 8.1CDU (Germany): 6.4Conservative Party (Canada): 7.0UK Labour: 3.2Likud (Israel): 8.2BJP (India): 9.3Fidesz (Hungary): 9.8Law and Justice (Poland): 9.6AKP (Turkey): 3.3AfD (Germany): 10.0National Rally (France): 9.7Vox (Spain): 9.9Sweden Democrats: 9.7FPO (Austria): 9.8PVV (Netherlands): 9.8Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 8.6Golden Dawn (Greece): 10.0United Russia: 7.0LiberalRestrictive

Republican Party: 8.9, 89th percentile of 755 parties. The median party scores 5.5. Closest named parties: Social Liberal Party (Brazil) (8.6), BJP (India) (9.3), Law and Justice (Poland) (9.6).

10.0 AfD (Germany)10.0 Golden Dawn (Greece)9.9 Vox (Spain)9.8 Fidesz (Hungary)9.8 FPO (Austria)9.8 PVV (Netherlands)9.7 Sweden Democrats9.7 National Rally (France)9.6 Law and Justice (Poland)9.3 BJP (India)8.9 Republican Party (US)8.6 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)8.2 Likud (Israel)8.1 UK Conservatives7.0 Conservative Party (Canada)7.0 United Russia6.4 CDU (Germany)3.3 AKP (Turkey)3.2 UK Labour2.7 Democratic Party (US)

Nationalism

Nationalism versus multilateralism. Scale reversed for display: in the file 0 strongly favors nationalism and 10 strongly favors multilateralism. File variable V13.
0246810Republican Party (US): 8.1Democratic Party (US): 1.7UK Conservatives: 7.3CDU (Germany): 2.2Conservative Party (Canada): 6.0UK Labour: 3.3Likud (Israel): 7.6BJP (India): 7.8Fidesz (Hungary): 8.8Law and Justice (Poland): 8.7AKP (Turkey): 8.7AfD (Germany): 9.3National Rally (France): 8.9Vox (Spain): 8.9Sweden Democrats: 8.3FPO (Austria): 9.2PVV (Netherlands): 9.2Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 8.8Golden Dawn (Greece): 9.9United Russia: 6.0MultilateralistNationalist

Republican Party: 8.1, 89th percentile of 793 parties. The median party scores 4.3. Closest named parties: Sweden Democrats (8.3), BJP (India) (7.8), Likud (Israel) (7.6).

9.9 Golden Dawn (Greece)9.3 AfD (Germany)9.2 PVV (Netherlands)9.2 FPO (Austria)8.9 National Rally (France)8.9 Vox (Spain)8.8 Fidesz (Hungary)8.8 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)8.7 AKP (Turkey)8.7 Law and Justice (Poland)8.3 Sweden Democrats8.1 Republican Party (US)7.8 BJP (India)7.6 Likud (Israel)7.3 UK Conservatives6.0 Conservative Party (Canada)6.0 United Russia3.3 UK Labour2.2 CDU (Germany)1.7 Democratic Party (US)

Ethnic minority rights

Position on rights for ethnic and racial minorities. File variable V15.
0246810Republican Party (US): 8.2Democratic Party (US): 1.7UK Conservatives: 5.8CDU (Germany): 5.0Conservative Party (Canada): 4.3UK Labour: 2.0Likud (Israel): 8.8BJP (India): 8.8Fidesz (Hungary): 4.8Law and Justice (Poland): 8.3AKP (Turkey): 8.3AfD (Germany): 9.7National Rally (France): 8.7Vox (Spain): 9.4Sweden Democrats: 8.3FPO (Austria): 8.9PVV (Netherlands): 9.8Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 9.3Golden Dawn (Greece): 10.0United Russia: 3.0Strongly favors rightsStrongly opposes rights

Republican Party: 8.2, 89th percentile of 767 parties. The median party scores 3.5. Closest named parties: Sweden Democrats (8.3), AKP (Turkey) (8.3), Law and Justice (Poland) (8.3).

10.0 Golden Dawn (Greece)9.8 PVV (Netherlands)9.7 AfD (Germany)9.4 Vox (Spain)9.3 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)8.9 FPO (Austria)8.8 BJP (India)8.8 Likud (Israel)8.7 National Rally (France)8.3 Law and Justice (Poland)8.3 AKP (Turkey)8.3 Sweden Democrats8.2 Republican Party (US)5.8 UK Conservatives5.0 CDU (Germany)4.8 Fidesz (Hungary)4.3 Conservative Party (Canada)3.0 United Russia2.0 UK Labour1.7 Democratic Party (US)

Women's rights

Position on women's rights. File variable V14.
0246810Republican Party (US): 7.1Democratic Party (US): 1.5UK Conservatives: 5.1CDU (Germany): 3.8Conservative Party (Canada): 6.0UK Labour: 2.2Likud (Israel): 3.8BJP (India): 6.6Fidesz (Hungary): 8.1Law and Justice (Poland): 8.6AKP (Turkey): 8.0AfD (Germany): 8.5National Rally (France): 5.4Vox (Spain): 9.0Sweden Democrats: 6.6FPO (Austria): 8.5PVV (Netherlands): 5.5Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 8.8Golden Dawn (Greece): 8.3United Russia: 8.4Strongly favors rightsStrongly opposes rights

Republican Party: 7.1, 87th percentile of 809 parties. The median party scores 3.5. Closest named parties: Sweden Democrats (6.6), BJP (India) (6.6), AKP (Turkey) (8.0).

9.0 Vox (Spain)8.8 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)8.6 Law and Justice (Poland)8.5 FPO (Austria)8.5 AfD (Germany)8.4 United Russia8.3 Golden Dawn (Greece)8.1 Fidesz (Hungary)8.0 AKP (Turkey)7.1 Republican Party (US)6.6 Sweden Democrats6.6 BJP (India)6.0 Conservative Party (Canada)5.5 PVV (Netherlands)5.4 National Rally (France)5.1 UK Conservatives3.8 CDU (Germany)3.8 Likud (Israel)2.2 UK Labour1.5 Democratic Party (US)

Respect for liberal democracy

Whether the party respects or undermines liberal democratic principles, norms and practices. File variable V16.
0246810Republican Party (US): 8.3Democratic Party (US): 2.2UK Conservatives: 6.0CDU (Germany): 1.4Conservative Party (Canada): 3.4UK Labour: 3.2Likud (Israel): 7.1BJP (India): 8.3Fidesz (Hungary): 9.4Law and Justice (Poland): 8.8AKP (Turkey): 9.6AfD (Germany): 9.2National Rally (France): 7.6Vox (Spain): 8.3Sweden Democrats: 6.2FPO (Austria): 7.8PVV (Netherlands): 6.9Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 8.9Golden Dawn (Greece): 9.8United Russia: 7.1Strongly respectsStrongly undermines

Republican Party: 8.3, 91st percentile of 803 parties. The median party scores 3.9. Closest named parties: Vox (Spain) (8.3), BJP (India) (8.3), FPO (Austria) (7.8).

9.8 Golden Dawn (Greece)9.6 AKP (Turkey)9.4 Fidesz (Hungary)9.2 AfD (Germany)8.9 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)8.8 Law and Justice (Poland)8.3 BJP (India)8.3 Vox (Spain)8.3 Republican Party (US)7.8 FPO (Austria)7.6 National Rally (France)7.1 United Russia7.1 Likud (Israel)6.9 PVV (Netherlands)6.2 Sweden Democrats6.0 UK Conservatives3.4 Conservative Party (Canada)3.2 UK Labour2.2 Democratic Party (US)1.4 CDU (Germany)

Checks on the executive

Strongman rule: whether the party favors checks and balances on the executive. File variable V21.
0246810Republican Party (US): 8.5Democratic Party (US): 1.9UK Conservatives: 7.8CDU (Germany): 2.2Conservative Party (Canada): 2.8UK Labour: 4.8Likud (Israel): 9.2BJP (India): 8.0Fidesz (Hungary): 9.4Law and Justice (Poland): 7.8AKP (Turkey): 9.1AfD (Germany): 7.0National Rally (France): 7.3Vox (Spain): 7.1Sweden Democrats: 4.5FPO (Austria): 7.0PVV (Netherlands): 7.5Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 8.8Golden Dawn (Greece): 9.3United Russia: 8.8Strongly favors checksStrongly opposes checks

Republican Party: 8.5, 92nd percentile of 796 parties. The median party scores 4.0. Closest named parties: United Russia (8.8), Social Liberal Party (Brazil) (8.8), BJP (India) (8.0).

9.4 Fidesz (Hungary)9.3 Golden Dawn (Greece)9.2 Likud (Israel)9.1 AKP (Turkey)8.8 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)8.8 United Russia8.5 Republican Party (US)8.0 BJP (India)7.8 UK Conservatives7.8 Law and Justice (Poland)7.5 PVV (Netherlands)7.3 National Rally (France)7.1 Vox (Spain)7.0 AfD (Germany)7.0 FPO (Austria)4.8 UK Labour4.5 Sweden Democrats2.8 Conservative Party (Canada)2.2 CDU (Germany)1.9 Democratic Party (US)

Source two: V-Dem's V-Party, 2015 to 2019

V-Party asks coders about each party before each election, and the strips use each party's latest coding between 2015 and 2019, for parties coded by at least four experts (414 parties). The Republican Party's latest coding is the November 2018 midterm, by 6 coders. The same dot colors apply. Where a scale runs low-to-high toward better behavior in the file, the strip is reversed so that a dot further right always means more of the trait named.

On V-Dem's anti-pluralism index the Republican Party scores 0.72 in 2018, the 80th percentile of 414 parties and above the median of 0.29. The named parties nearest it are AfD (Germany) (0.66), Law and Justice (Poland) (0.80), Brothers of Italy (0.85). The index was lower in earlier years, as the table shows.

0.35 20000.32 20020.32 20040.36 20060.37 20080.35 20100.45 20120.48 20140.69 20160.72 2018

Anti-pluralism index

Composite index of how far a party lacks commitment to democratic norms before elections: demonizing opponents, rejecting political violence, minority rights and pluralism. File variable v2xpa_antiplural.
00.20.40.60.81Republican Party (US): 0.7Democratic Party (US): 0.3CDU (Germany): 0.0Fidesz (Hungary): 0.9Law and Justice (Poland): 0.8AKP (Turkey): 1.0United Russia: 0.9AfD (Germany): 0.7Brothers of Italy: 0.8North League (Italy): 0.9Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 0.9Sweden Democrats: 0.1Golden Dawn (Greece): 1.0Committed to democratic normsNot committed

Republican Party: 0.72, 80th percentile of 414 parties. The median party scores 0.29. Closest named parties: AfD (Germany) (0.66), Law and Justice (Poland) (0.80), Brothers of Italy (0.85).

1.00 Golden Dawn (Greece)1.00 AKP (Turkey)0.95 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)0.91 United Russia0.91 Fidesz (Hungary)0.90 North League (Italy)0.85 Brothers of Italy0.80 Law and Justice (Poland)0.72 Republican Party (US)0.66 AfD (Germany)0.28 Democratic Party (US)0.10 Sweden Democrats0.05 CDU (Germany)

Demonizing political opponents

Do leaders use severe personal attacks or demonize opponents, calling them an existential threat, criminals, subversives or foreign agents? Scale reversed for display: in the file 0 is always demonizes and 4 is never. File variable v2paopresp_osp.
01234Republican Party (US): 3.3Democratic Party (US): 1.6CDU (Germany): 0.6Fidesz (Hungary): 3.9Law and Justice (Poland): 3.6AKP (Turkey): 3.9United Russia: 1.4AfD (Germany): 3.0Brothers of Italy: 2.6North League (Italy): 2.5Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 3.6Sweden Democrats: 0.5Golden Dawn (Greece): 4.0NeverAlways

Republican Party: 3.3, 89th percentile of 414 parties. The median party scores 1.6. Closest named parties: AfD (Germany) (3.0), Law and Justice (Poland) (3.6), Social Liberal Party (Brazil) (3.6).

4.0 Golden Dawn (Greece)3.9 AKP (Turkey)3.9 Fidesz (Hungary)3.6 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)3.6 Law and Justice (Poland)3.3 Republican Party (US)3.0 AfD (Germany)2.6 Brothers of Italy2.5 North League (Italy)1.6 Democratic Party (US)1.4 United Russia0.6 CDU (Germany)0.5 Sweden Democrats

Encouraging political violence

Do leaders discourage violence against domestic political opponents? Scale reversed for display: in the file 0 is encourages and 4 is consistently discourages. File variable v2paviol_osp.
01234Republican Party (US): 1.5Democratic Party (US): 0.1CDU (Germany): 0.1Fidesz (Hungary): 1.7Law and Justice (Poland): 1.5AKP (Turkey): 3.4United Russia: 2.2AfD (Germany): 1.0National Front (France): 1.2Brothers of Italy: 2.0North League (Italy): 2.4Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 2.1Sweden Democrats: 0.2PVV (Netherlands): 0.6Golden Dawn (Greece): 3.9Consistently discourages violenceEncourages violence

Republican Party: 1.5, 79th percentile of 413 parties. The median party scores 0.6. Closest named parties: Law and Justice (Poland) (1.5), Fidesz (Hungary) (1.7), National Front (France) (1.2).

3.9 Golden Dawn (Greece)3.4 AKP (Turkey)2.4 North League (Italy)2.2 United Russia2.1 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)2.0 Brothers of Italy1.7 Fidesz (Hungary)1.5 Republican Party (US)1.5 Law and Justice (Poland)1.2 National Front (France)1.0 AfD (Germany)0.6 PVV (Netherlands)0.2 Sweden Democrats0.1 CDU (Germany)0.1 Democratic Party (US)

Overriding minority rights

How often should the majority's will override minority rights, in the party's view? Scale reversed for display: in the file 0 is always and 4 is never. File variable v2paminor_osp.
01234Republican Party (US): 2.9Democratic Party (US): 2.4CDU (Germany): 1.1Fidesz (Hungary): 3.3Law and Justice (Poland): 2.9AKP (Turkey): 3.1United Russia: 3.1AfD (Germany): 3.4National Front (France): 2.0Brothers of Italy: 2.7North League (Italy): 3.2Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 3.5Sweden Democrats: 1.1Golden Dawn (Greece): 3.7Never overridesAlways overrides

Republican Party: 2.9, 87th percentile of 402 parties. The median party scores 1.3. Closest named parties: Law and Justice (Poland) (2.9), Brothers of Italy (2.7), AKP (Turkey) (3.1).

3.7 Golden Dawn (Greece)3.5 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)3.4 AfD (Germany)3.3 Fidesz (Hungary)3.2 North League (Italy)3.1 United Russia3.1 AKP (Turkey)2.9 Republican Party (US)2.9 Law and Justice (Poland)2.7 Brothers of Italy2.4 Democratic Party (US)2.0 National Front (France)1.1 Sweden Democrats1.1 CDU (Germany)

Commitment to free elections and free speech

Commitment to free and fair multiparty elections and freedom of speech, media, assembly and association. Scale reversed for display: in the file 0 is not at all committed and 4 is fully committed. File variable v2paplur_osp.
01234Republican Party (US): 1.1Democratic Party (US): 0.7CDU (Germany): 0.2Fidesz (Hungary): 1.7Law and Justice (Poland): 1.4AKP (Turkey): 3.7United Russia: 2.4AfD (Germany): 0.9National Front (France): 0.7Brothers of Italy: 1.8North League (Italy): 1.8Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 2.1Sweden Democrats: 0.5PVV (Netherlands): 0.2Golden Dawn (Greece): 3.3Fully committedNot at all committed

Republican Party: 1.1, 67th percentile of 421 parties. The median party scores 0.7. Closest named parties: AfD (Germany) (0.9), Law and Justice (Poland) (1.4), National Front (France) (0.7).

3.7 AKP (Turkey)3.3 Golden Dawn (Greece)2.4 United Russia2.1 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)1.8 Brothers of Italy1.8 North League (Italy)1.7 Fidesz (Hungary)1.4 Law and Justice (Poland)1.1 Republican Party (US)0.9 AfD (Germany)0.7 National Front (France)0.7 Democratic Party (US)0.5 Sweden Democrats0.2 PVV (Netherlands)0.2 CDU (Germany)

Promoting group or national superiority

Does the party promote the superiority of a group or the nation? Scale reversed for display: in the file 0 is strongly promotes and 4 is strongly opposes. File variable v2paculsup_osp.
01234Republican Party (US): 2.7Democratic Party (US): 0.9CDU (Germany): 1.6Fidesz (Hungary): 3.8Law and Justice (Poland): 3.7AKP (Turkey): 3.4United Russia: 3.0AfD (Germany): 3.8National Front (France): 3.8Brothers of Italy: 3.4North League (Italy): 3.4Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 3.3Sweden Democrats: 2.8Golden Dawn (Greece): 3.9Strongly opposesStrongly promotes

Republican Party: 2.7, 80th percentile of 410 parties. The median party scores 1.8. Closest named parties: Sweden Democrats (2.8), United Russia (3.0), Social Liberal Party (Brazil) (3.3).

3.9 Golden Dawn (Greece)3.8 National Front (France)3.8 Fidesz (Hungary)3.8 AfD (Germany)3.7 Law and Justice (Poland)3.4 AKP (Turkey)3.4 North League (Italy)3.4 Brothers of Italy3.3 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)3.0 United Russia2.8 Sweden Democrats2.7 Republican Party (US)1.6 CDU (Germany)0.9 Democratic Party (US)

A party built around one leader

Is the party a vehicle for one leader's personal will? 0 is not focused on one leader and 4 is solely focused. File variable v2paind_osp.
01234Republican Party (US): 1.5Democratic Party (US): 0.2CDU (Germany): 1.0Fidesz (Hungary): 4.0Law and Justice (Poland): 3.2AKP (Turkey): 4.0United Russia: 2.7AfD (Germany): 0.5National Front (France): 3.1Brothers of Italy: 2.2North League (Italy): 3.1Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 2.8Golden Dawn (Greece): 3.4Not focused on one leaderSolely focused on one leader

Republican Party: 1.5, 46th percentile of 405 parties. The median party scores 1.7. Closest named parties: CDU (Germany) (1.0), Brothers of Italy (2.2), AfD (Germany) (0.5).

4.0 AKP (Turkey)4.0 Fidesz (Hungary)3.4 Golden Dawn (Greece)3.2 Law and Justice (Poland)3.1 National Front (France)3.1 North League (Italy)2.8 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)2.7 United Russia2.2 Brothers of Italy1.5 Republican Party (US)1.0 CDU (Germany)0.5 AfD (Germany)0.2 Democratic Party (US)

Populism index

Harmonic mean of anti-elitism and people-centrism. File variable v2xpa_popul.
00.20.40.60.81Republican Party (US): 0.5Democratic Party (US): 0.3CDU (Germany): 0.1Fidesz (Hungary): 0.8Law and Justice (Poland): 0.9AKP (Turkey): 1.0United Russia: 0.1AfD (Germany): 1.0Brothers of Italy: 0.7North League (Italy): 0.8Social Liberal Party (Brazil): 0.3Sweden Democrats: 0.9Golden Dawn (Greece): 1.0Not populistPopulist

Republican Party: 0.54, 70th percentile of 414 parties. The median party scores 0.38. Closest named parties: Brothers of Italy (0.65), Social Liberal Party (Brazil) (0.35), Democratic Party (US) (0.32).

0.97 Golden Dawn (Greece)0.96 AKP (Turkey)0.95 AfD (Germany)0.94 Law and Justice (Poland)0.86 Sweden Democrats0.85 North League (Italy)0.83 Fidesz (Hungary)0.65 Brothers of Italy0.54 Republican Party (US)0.35 Social Liberal Party (Brazil)0.32 Democratic Party (US)0.10 United Russia0.06 CDU (Germany)

The trait grid: regimes of the 1920s to 1970s on the same instruments

V-Dem's country-year dataset (v16) codes every country every year on the same expert-built indices, back to 1789. Each cell is the average of that index across the years shown, on a 0 to 1 scale where 1 is the most democratic or most free. The historical regimes sit on the same ruler as the Republican years, so the grid compares like with like. Orange cells are low, aqua cells high. Party-trait scores like the strips above do not exist before 1970, so this grid measures the regimes' conditions, not a party's rhetoric.
Country and periodYearsElectoral democracyClean electionsFree expression and mediaFree associationFreedom from political violenceCourts constrain the executiveLegislature constrains the executiveLiberal democracy
Historical regimes
Fascist Italy1925 to 19430.060.110.050.060.230.090.020.03
Nazi Germany1934 to 19440.080.020.040.030.020.050.060.01
Franco's Spain1940 to 19750.080.050.040.040.140.330.050.06
Salazar and Caetano's Portugal1933 to 19740.120.060.090.090.240.390.040.08
Horthy's Hungary1920 to 19430.310.410.530.370.550.770.590.25
Perón's Argentina1946 to 19550.340.650.230.610.500.390.370.19
Pinochet's Chile1974 to 19890.080.000.050.090.070.28n/a0.04
Recent decades, other countries
Hungary under Orbán2010 to 20250.570.730.720.740.960.720.600.45
Poland under Law and Justice2016 to 20230.650.840.690.840.910.600.740.49
Turkey under Erdoğan2014 to 20250.310.450.180.580.430.250.210.13
Russia under Putin2012 to 20250.240.290.300.270.320.070.130.09
Brazil under Bolsonaro2019 to 20220.690.870.680.880.460.820.790.53
Denmark2015 to 20250.920.960.990.930.970.990.980.89
United States, by period
United States 2001 to 20082001 to 20080.860.880.980.940.870.950.940.80
United States 2009 to 20162009 to 20160.900.940.980.940.950.960.950.85
United States 2017 to 20202017 to 20200.820.860.930.950.930.940.870.74
United States 2021 to 20242021 to 20240.840.870.950.940.950.920.920.77
United States 202520250.730.900.770.910.790.840.610.57
Sources. (1) Pippa Norris, Global Party Survey, 2019, V3, Harvard Dataverse, doi:10.7910/DVN/WMGTNS, public domain dedication (CC0); experts rated parties between November 19 and December 20, 2019; only parties rated by at least five experts are plotted. (2) V-Dem Country-Year Dataset v16 (Coppedge et al., 2026, doi:10.23696/vdemds26, CC BY-SA 4.0) for the trait grid. (3) Lindberg et al., Varieties of Party Identity and Organization (V-Party) Dataset V2, V-Dem Project, 2022, doi:10.23696/vpartydsv2, read from the vdemdata release on GitHub. Values are expert estimates for each party as published; nothing was adjusted except the reversed scales, each noted on its strip. The two surveys were not mixed on any strip.

Related pages: Fascism, Authoritarianism, Populism, Nationalism and Nativism, Democracy.